Интересное мнение.
Это я спорю сам с собой и с Beyond Mirrors Yello.
http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=231#more-231
Там в комментах есть:
Caliban, I used to be a mathematician with a specialty interest in formal logic and axiomatic systems. Godel’s incompleteness theorem only applies to formal axiomatic deduction, which is a far more constrained form of “description” than we have for the real universe (in which, for example, the so-called “Law” of the Excluded Middle normally does not apply). If you try to apply Godel’s theorem outside its proper domain, all you will get is impressive-sounding nonsense.
Поэтому часть посылок Beyond Mirrors, которую я рассматриваю как манифест магического восприятия мира, неверна. Точнее, одна посылка. ;)
Что интересно и радует.
http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=231#more-231
Там в комментах есть:
Caliban, I used to be a mathematician with a specialty interest in formal logic and axiomatic systems. Godel’s incompleteness theorem only applies to formal axiomatic deduction, which is a far more constrained form of “description” than we have for the real universe (in which, for example, the so-called “Law” of the Excluded Middle normally does not apply). If you try to apply Godel’s theorem outside its proper domain, all you will get is impressive-sounding nonsense.
Поэтому часть посылок Beyond Mirrors, которую я рассматриваю как манифест магического восприятия мира, неверна. Точнее, одна посылка. ;)
Что интересно и радует.