Half a theory
I know this is purely ancedotal evidence, but it always seems to me that when someone thinks they know where a show is going/call future plots, if they are right at all, they are usually only half right. Sometimes though, the person they tell that theory to will whack off the faulty edges of the first persons theory, insert a new fact and together, they form a perfect key.
My roommate and I totally did that with Dexter tonight. He gave me his theory for the rest of the season, and I immediately filled in the holes in his theory, once filled, it all came together and made sense. Now I'm kinda sad though, because while I still don't know the hows of the rest of the season, I'm fairly certain I know the whys. Worse, if we're wrong, it's doubtful the actual solution could actually be better than our solution.
My roommate and I totally did that with Dexter tonight. He gave me his theory for the rest of the season, and I immediately filled in the holes in his theory, once filled, it all came together and made sense. Now I'm kinda sad though, because while I still don't know the hows of the rest of the season, I'm fairly certain I know the whys. Worse, if we're wrong, it's doubtful the actual solution could actually be better than our solution.