Challenge 02 Round 07 Results

Oct 21, 2008 21:07

I'm so sorry, but we have to say "goodbye" to some participants.



Eliminated:


vani11a_fox with 3 votes



djalina with 3 votes

People's Choice:


alice_trip with 3 votes

Mod's Choice:

No Mc.

Did you forget your icon number? You can find it HERE

Voting Tally:
01| -2+1= -1
02| -3
03| -4+1= -3
04| +3
05| -1+2= +1
06| -2+3= +1

Favourite icons
1 - the most interesting bw icon from listed. Nothing extra.

003 - amazing composition and colors

004 - good crop, nice b/w colors
4 - красивый кроп и ч/б исполнение
04 - nice rotation, crop and contrast

05 - very pretty use of b&w
5 - icon is nicely sharp and cropping is great

6 - nice colors
6 - like crop, coloring, use of tiny-text. The most attractive work.
6 - пик (кроп, композиция, осенние цвета) пронизан удивительным шармом!

Lesser quality icons
001 - too light, the light texture doesn't fit the icon
1 - icon is really blurry and light texture doesn't make it look better

2 - немного смущает кроп из-за обрезанной руки
2 - too simple icon
2 - icon's bit blurry, it lacks some decoration (text or anything) - too much free space on the left.

3 - icon is blurry and those leaves are overpowering..
3 - красивая идея, но сама Шарлиз очень плохого качества
03 - it's original and the composition is pretty, but the photo itself is pale, too purple and a bit blurry
3 - leaves are too distracting

5 - crop is boring and a bit tight, her scarf and hat are oversharpened.

06 - it could do without the text, it's not very well placed for this crop and partially "invisible"
006 - the tiny-text isn't really good, in colors there are too much yellow

challenge_02, results, round_07

Previous post Next post
Up