Round 01 | Challenge 01 | Results
Thanks for voting everyone! It was really close!
Elimination
by faded_color
People's Choice
by kateliciously
Points
2 points for FIRST CHOICE
1 point for SECOND CHOICE
- for negative/least favorite
*Points shown are totals
1: 1 -2 = -1
2: 5 00 = 05
3: 4 00 = 04
4: 1 -3 = -2
5: 0 -2 = -2
6: 7 00 = 07
7: 3 00 = 03
*Eliminated icon was deducted by the one with the most negative votes. In the case of a tie, the one with the most negative (for elimination icons) or positive (for tied winning icons) loses or wins.
Positive Comments
01: the crop is great
02: great crop and colouring. good crop, nice and simple. I really like how clear the icon is. The cropping is nice, and the coloring is good. I really like the crop on your icon, and the way you've managed to keep it light, but keep good contrast. It looks a little grainy on my monitor, but it's still a good icon.
03: the coloring is plain, simple and crisp. Love it. I like the crop and how the coloring makes the TARDIS stand out.
04: The coloring doesn't overpower the image and it's still clear and gorgeous.
05: n/a
06: The cropping and coloring is appealing, it has nice composition, and it's very crisp without being too over sharpened. love the color and crop. I really love the crop, and I think the coloring goes well. Lovely composition!
07 The texture provides a nice touch to the icon, and the cropping is nice. I like the cropping and positioning of the levels.
Negative Comments:
01: I think the subject is really pretty, but not clear enough. It could use maybe some sharpening. Some bright tones would make it pop, I believe. A little better quality could work as well. :) The coloring just seems really flat on your icon - I think it could have used more contrast so the contours of Sierra's face really stood out.
02: n/a
03: n/a
04: There are places that are over sharpened (ian's neckline, nina's arm) and the texture does not really compliment the icon, it's a bit distracting. i like the texture on the right side of the icon, how it looks like a border, but maybe if the texture was faded in spots on their bodies, it wouldn't be as distracting. I love Delena but the icon is far to pixel-y. the contrast is a bit too high, and the texture too strong/out of place towards the top and on the right.
05: The image seems so dark the sepia drowns the image out. The icon seems blurry and the texture used takes attention away from their faces.
06: n/a
07: n/a
IMS/Skips Left
ablackmagician (1 skip left)
firedawn (1 skip left)
midnightisclose (2 skips left)
rocketgirl2 (2 skips left)
kateliciously (2 skips left)
laurenelizabeth9 (2 skips left)
erinm_4600 (1 skip left)
dyskie (2 skips left)
faded_color
*If you did not submit an icon, a skip will be taken. If you submit but do not vote, a skip will be taken.
Second challenge will be up next.
Elimination
by faded_color
People's Choice
by kateliciously
Points
2 points for FIRST CHOICE
1 point for SECOND CHOICE
- for negative/least favorite
*Points shown are totals
1: 1 -2 = -1
2: 5 00 = 05
3: 4 00 = 04
4: 1 -3 = -2
5: 0 -2 = -2
6: 7 00 = 07
7: 3 00 = 03
*Eliminated icon was deducted by the one with the most negative votes. In the case of a tie, the one with the most negative (for elimination icons) or positive (for tied winning icons) loses or wins.
Positive Comments
01: the crop is great
02: great crop and colouring. good crop, nice and simple. I really like how clear the icon is. The cropping is nice, and the coloring is good. I really like the crop on your icon, and the way you've managed to keep it light, but keep good contrast. It looks a little grainy on my monitor, but it's still a good icon.
03: the coloring is plain, simple and crisp. Love it. I like the crop and how the coloring makes the TARDIS stand out.
04: The coloring doesn't overpower the image and it's still clear and gorgeous.
05: n/a
06: The cropping and coloring is appealing, it has nice composition, and it's very crisp without being too over sharpened. love the color and crop. I really love the crop, and I think the coloring goes well. Lovely composition!
07 The texture provides a nice touch to the icon, and the cropping is nice. I like the cropping and positioning of the levels.
Negative Comments:
01: I think the subject is really pretty, but not clear enough. It could use maybe some sharpening. Some bright tones would make it pop, I believe. A little better quality could work as well. :) The coloring just seems really flat on your icon - I think it could have used more contrast so the contours of Sierra's face really stood out.
02: n/a
03: n/a
04: There are places that are over sharpened (ian's neckline, nina's arm) and the texture does not really compliment the icon, it's a bit distracting. i like the texture on the right side of the icon, how it looks like a border, but maybe if the texture was faded in spots on their bodies, it wouldn't be as distracting. I love Delena but the icon is far to pixel-y. the contrast is a bit too high, and the texture too strong/out of place towards the top and on the right.
05: The image seems so dark the sepia drowns the image out. The icon seems blurry and the texture used takes attention away from their faces.
06: n/a
07: n/a
IMS/Skips Left
ablackmagician (1 skip left)
firedawn (1 skip left)
midnightisclose (2 skips left)
rocketgirl2 (2 skips left)
kateliciously (2 skips left)
laurenelizabeth9 (2 skips left)
erinm_4600 (1 skip left)
dyskie (2 skips left)
faded_color
*If you did not submit an icon, a skip will be taken. If you submit but do not vote, a skip will be taken.
Second challenge will be up next.