results: challenge nine [round two[

[sourpony]

Comments

[narniacmr]

Comments for #4 please, unscreened is fine :)

[sourpony]

- I don't think the pink background goes very well with the image. In the icon, Rose's top looks more purply, so I think a colour more like this would suit it better

[neke]

Congratulations to everybody who got through!

I have to admit I'm gutted but also glad I don't have to make an icon for the next round. One less thing on my to-do list. ^^

Okay. Hit me with it. Comments for #3 please. Unscreened is fine with me.

[sourpony]

Congrats on Top 4 though!

- The crop of this icon is really nice, but there's a lot of detail in the Doctor and Rose's face that have been lost.
- appears oversaturated and very sharp.
- The colouring seems too over saturated

+ I love the strong orange colouring! It's a great simplistic icon

[neke]

Thanks! When I started this I never ever thought I would get this far, so I guess that's an achievement in itself. ^^

[tinitrinity]

Wow. That's a surprise. Thanks y'all :)
May I have the comments for #1 please? Unscreened is fine.

[sourpony]

- First of all, this was a really hard decision and this icon is by no means bad.
There are a couple of distracting things in this icon. The yellow 6 which is also slightly too sharp. The white 'smudge' texture. Her arm. They all distract from what I think should draw the focus, namely the subject and in particular her face.

+ the composition and coloring are really good. just really great use of a cap/
+ beautiful cropping/colouring
+ The whole composition is gorgeous

[wildalyss]

comments for #2 please :)

[sourpony]

- image blurry

+ Good coloring. I like the use of center crop. Nice background.