challenge 5 results

Apr 08, 2008 02:31

Still lots of ties, and only few comments this time, but anyways...


These are the votes everyone got...

01. 7 votes - 1st place (airelin)
02. 1 vote - 7th place (untasted)
03. 0 votes - 10th place (dragonflyopera)
04. 4 votes - 4th place (sidhex3)
05. 3 votes - 6th place (r3nn4)
06. 7 votes - 1st place (sunflower_pixie)
07. 4 votes - 4th place (general_nothing)
08. 0 votes - 10th place (so_severus)
09. 1 votes - 7th place (handsofclay)
10. 1 votes - 7th place (lillianporter)
11. 5 votes - 3rd place (katie2703)

You can see the updated scores here.
If anybody would like a banner please let me know :) (I'll get to the ones I'm still due tomorrow ;) )

comments the icons got - if your number isn't listed, you didn't get any comments.
check your icon number here

01.
- Nice colour scheme that isn't too overpowering. The composition is good, with interesting text placement and colour variation.
- At first I was frustrated by the language barrier... until I saw the translation. :) Even though the text is small, it has nice texture and color and placement so that the eye is drawn to it first.
- good font choice and positioning

02.
- I just love the feel of this one. The colours somehow match the wording perfectly.

04.
- The larger words and the "oh" are a bit too bold and fuzzy, but the font and style variations of the text match the phrase beautifully.
- The text just seems to pop out at you. Nice work.

05.
- it does what it says on the tin! The positioning of the text, the mixture of fonts, and the touches of colour are interesting.

06.
- Good use of texture and the variation in text size makes it easy to read and more interesting.
- The small variations in the text make it visually interesting, and the sizing is well done. Plus it's a fun quote and it fills the space nicely.

07.
- Good combination of textures, good font colour choice as it is readable on the dark background. Plus, great text XD

09.
- the icon has variety; the text is positioned well relative to the texture/background; the fonts are well-chosen.

11.
- the text fits well on the texture/background; the different fonts and the positioning 'act out' the text.
- the 2nd and 3rd lines of text don't appear aligned to the first, but the quote is too funny to make a difference.
- I wasn't sure about this one at first, but it seems to be growing on me. Neat idea.

Please let me know if you discover any mistakes^^

round 1 challenge 5, round 1, challenge 5, results

Previous post Next post
Up