HARRY EFFIN POTTER, HOOKERS.

Nov 18, 2005 03:41

I just want to put it out there that HP&tGoF is the best thing to happen. Ever. Yet ( Read more... )

Leave a comment

poivrepauvre November 18 2005, 23:32:45 UTC
I love the books, I just think the fourth movie doesn't do the book justice AT ALL. It was more about looks than substance, and any substance that was tehre was a lot of the times not accurate or just completely made up. I was looking forward to more of Rowling's genious being portrayed than that of the graphic designer's.

~Robbie

Reply

testificatio November 19 2005, 20:42:01 UTC
I'll remind you, my friend, that J.K. Rowling has complete authority over what's left out in the films. Anything that wasn't there is ok with her.

Reply

poivrepauvre November 20 2005, 06:44:46 UTC
ok, that makes me feel much better. I wasn't aware of that, but now that I think about it, it seems to be the only logical thing... I feel stupid now, lol... but I still think some parts should have been included that weren't.

Reply

molly4114 November 20 2005, 15:59:24 UTC
Funny you say that. I really enjoyed that a lot of time wasn't spent on the intricacies of the plot; it just kept going assuming that the audience understood what was happening. In this respect, I thought it followed the book rather well -- because those who have read the book would get it and like it most. A movie for the book fans, not the movie fans. Y'know?

Reply

poivrepauvre November 20 2005, 17:17:42 UTC
and although I am a book fan, it still bothered me that some of my friends who aren't will get confused during the movie. That wasn't something I liked.

Reply


Leave a comment

Up