round 2 challenge 2 results
VOTED OFF
by gem_pinkeh
by waybeyondempty_
Thanks for your entries, hope you stick around for future votings and then sign up again for the next round :)
PEOPLE'S CHOICE
by homoprinsessa
MOD'S CHOICE
by catharsis_o_s
very nicely brightened up + coloured, and I like the tiny repetition^^
If any of you wants a banner let me know in a comment. Banners will be made for people's choice and mod's choice.
The entries again:
001
002
003
004
005
006
007
008
009
010
011
012
013
014
the voting results:
01. -12
02. -1 +3 = +2
03. -6 +5 = -1
04. +4
05. -1 +2 = 0
06. +2
07. -6
08. 0
09. -3 +1 = -2
10. -3 +3 = 0
11. -6 +1 = -5
12. -1 +6 = +5
13. -4 +1 = -3
14. -1 +2 = +1
the reasons given for the votes:
01. negative: 12 | positive: 0
- The image is too dark.
- The image is too dark and the font is too sharp
- coloring is too dark and blue/purple. the font face is an awkward choice for the word and the smaller text below is illegible but too big to be tiny text.
- David's face is too dark (not enough light contrast)
- The coloring is too dark, the font trite, and the text doesn't really fit the image.
- He's too purple and his skin looks muddled.
- The image is too dark and doesn't seem to have been improved much from the original screencap, also text is hard to read.
- The icon is too dark and seems to saturated
- it's really dark, and a bit too blueish.
- Image is very dark
- The colouring is too dark and uneven and the text is hard to read.
- It's very dark and slightly over-saturated for that amount of darkness
02. negative: 1 | positive: 3
- It's a bit over-saturated which makes the extremities very red, especially around the eyes
+ Gorgeous coloring and cute crop.
+ For some reason with the colouring and the blocks and the expression on his face, it's like DI Carlisle just discovered something in kindergarten. Very cute, I love it.
+ no comment
03. negative: 6 | positive: 5
- The crop takes away from the image
- the icon is too busy, the different colouring of the two different halves is jarring.
- There's too much going on. It's hard to focus on David, or more specifically, which David.
- Interesting idea, but overlaying and cropping of Carlisle's face is unflattering.
- There is just waaayy too much going on with all the duplications of the image and the background texture.
- It's a nice idea but the colouring is a bit odd and the bottom two images are slightly under-sharpened compared to the top two.
+ beautiful coloring, interesting and effective use of double image, nice texture work.
+ great effect
+ Love the coloring and that whole fragmented effect.
+ Very original and love the colouring
+ no comment
04. negative: 0 | positive: 4
+ I like the crop and texture used.
+ I like the colouring, the brush and the cropping :)
+ no comment
+ no comment
05. negative: 1 | positive: 2
- there is no contrast, it looks really flat.
+ Love the split contrast and colouring between the left and right side.
+ no comment
06. negative: 0 | positive: 2
+ nicely colored, good text placement, sharpened but not oversharpened.
+ I love the colouring and the lighting and the big text. Nicely done.
07. negative: 6 | positive: 0
- The texture doesn't really work with the image and it over powers the icon.
- poor image quality. the colors of the texture and the text do not match the coloring of the cap. awkward cropping.
- the use of coloring does not compliment the picture
- no enough contrast
- Blurry image and odd coloring on him. Background doesn't really go, either.
- David looks blurry and the background is distracting
09. negative: 3 | positive: 1
- The icon looks plan in comparison to the other images.
- It seems little has been done, and the right side looks too empty.
- The horizontal flip doesn't look right and it's very plain
+ no comment
10. negative: 3 | positive: 3
- Everything is way too sharp, the texture over powers the icon, and the font is too pixelated.
- The halftone texture doesn't work well and the cropping seems off
- The image is too sharp and there's too much going on with the patter and the blurring and all the very tiny text.
+ love the texture and the repeated image
+ no comment
+ no comment
11. negative: 6 | positive: 1
- the colouring is very washed out
- Image is a bit blurry and the coloring is a bit washed-out.
- The skin colour on his face looks out of place with the darker colours in his mouth and especially in his eyes
+ Nice crop, nice coloring.
12. negative: 1 | positive: 6
- Not enough ontrast in the image
+ I like the black and white coloring and the text.
+ A simple idea but elegant.
+ Another original idea, I like the black and white =)
+ Good use of contrast, I like the crop
+ no comment
+ no comment
13. negative: 4 | positive: 1
- the coloring of the cap itself isn't bad but the texture doesn't work and the texture is erased too much at one point on his shoulder. the edge of the texture is oversharp.
- the icons looks over-sharpened
- the edges on David looks pixelated in places
- Icon seems oversharp
+ Brilliant coloring; nice crop.
14. negative: 1 | positive: 2
- I like the text, but the coloring makes the image look washed out.
+ I love the crop, and the text is just perfect!
+ I like the colouring and the text made me smile :)
let me know if I made any mistakes^^
the new challenge will be posted later tonight.