WAR 01 BATTLE 02: RESULTS
After much delay, here are the results!
BATTLE 02 ELIMINATIONS
We have five eliminations this week due to three not submitting on time, with an addition of two who had the least points. There were no participants with 0 points, so unfortunately the two with the least number of points have been eliminated.
The following soldiers have been eliminated for not submitting with no sick days left:
The following soldiers have been eliminated for having the least points:
with 4 points
with 4 points
Note: There was actually a 4-way tie, but this tie was broken based on who had the least favourite points from the previous two rounds.
Also, there WILL be a Comeback Round for those who have been eliminated, so don't despair!
BATTLE 02 CITIZENS' CHOICE AWARDS
(#02 - Sailor Scouts) // +19 points
(#01 - Sailor Scouts) // +12 points
* Comment to this post if you two would like banners.
BATTLE 02 GENERALS' CHOICE AWARDS
(#06 - All other soldiers)
kanrinin: Very authentic colouring! When I first saw the icon, I thought the background was part of the original image, but it wasn't, which surprised me. Also, the light blues of Rei's hair was utilized in a beautiful way, which added to the idyllic feel the icon had. Lastly, the typography is quite good, and fills up the space nicely. Terrific job!
(#02 - All Other Soldiers)
redone: I find the textures used and the soft, gentle, ethereal colouring really mesh together very well. The image and text choice is also very fitting - all most as if we can really imagine her wondering where the stars went! My only issue might be the brightness of Sayaka, compared with the background, and a more mellow colour scheme to her clothing would be better. But such a minor thing would not affect my opinion over the icon overall.
kanrinin's runner-ups: #04 (All other soldiers), #04 (Sailor Scouts)
redone's runner-ups: #05 (All Other Soldiers), #03 (All Other Soldiers)
BATTLE 02 POINT GAIN/LOSS
+3 Points
1. Fuji Shuusuke
+2 Points
2. Mitani Yuuki
+1 Points
3. Kiba
4. Takishima Kei
5. Yuuri
+0 Points
6. Mitsuru Kirijo
6. C.C
6. Uchiha Sasuke
-1 Point
7. (General)
8. Tsukino Usagi
-2 Points
9. Presea
10. Aya-chan
BATTLE 02 RESULTS TALLIES
Sailor Scouts
1. +8 (+4) = +12 points
2. +11 (+8) = +19 points
3. -14 points
4. +2, -2 = 0 points
5. -5 points
Other Warriors
1. -7 points
2. -1, +6 = +5 points
3. +2, -2 = 0 points
4. -1, +1 = 0 points
5. -9, +3 = -6 points
6. +5 (+2) = +7 points
7. +5, -2 = +3 points
Link to voting table.
Icons were given +2 battle points for a priority 1 fave vote, +1 for a priority 2 fave vote, -2 for a priority 1 negative vote, -1 for a priority 2 negative vote, and +2 for an overall fave vote. Icons were then ranked based on number of battle points and organized into ranking quartiles, then given war points or had war points taken away based on that ranking. If any part of that is unclear, please let me know.
There were two eliminations during this battle.
If you would like your critiques, please leave a comment with the number of your icon and your avatar name. We will reply with a list of all the good/bad crits you received. ALL REPLIES WILL BE SCREENED, so if you do not get comments e-mailed to you, tell us and we will email the crits to you. Note: Some of the crits were VERY harsh. Do not ask for your critiques unless you're sure you can handle it. All crits will be kept 100% anonymous.
BATTLE 02 ELIMINATIONS
We have five eliminations this week due to three not submitting on time, with an addition of two who had the least points. There were no participants with 0 points, so unfortunately the two with the least number of points have been eliminated.
The following soldiers have been eliminated for not submitting with no sick days left:
The following soldiers have been eliminated for having the least points:
with 4 points
with 4 points
Note: There was actually a 4-way tie, but this tie was broken based on who had the least favourite points from the previous two rounds.
Also, there WILL be a Comeback Round for those who have been eliminated, so don't despair!
BATTLE 02 CITIZENS' CHOICE AWARDS
(#02 - Sailor Scouts) // +19 points
(#01 - Sailor Scouts) // +12 points
* Comment to this post if you two would like banners.
BATTLE 02 GENERALS' CHOICE AWARDS
(#06 - All other soldiers)
kanrinin: Very authentic colouring! When I first saw the icon, I thought the background was part of the original image, but it wasn't, which surprised me. Also, the light blues of Rei's hair was utilized in a beautiful way, which added to the idyllic feel the icon had. Lastly, the typography is quite good, and fills up the space nicely. Terrific job!
(#02 - All Other Soldiers)
redone: I find the textures used and the soft, gentle, ethereal colouring really mesh together very well. The image and text choice is also very fitting - all most as if we can really imagine her wondering where the stars went! My only issue might be the brightness of Sayaka, compared with the background, and a more mellow colour scheme to her clothing would be better. But such a minor thing would not affect my opinion over the icon overall.
kanrinin's runner-ups: #04 (All other soldiers), #04 (Sailor Scouts)
redone's runner-ups: #05 (All Other Soldiers), #03 (All Other Soldiers)
BATTLE 02 POINT GAIN/LOSS
+3 Points
1. Fuji Shuusuke
+2 Points
2. Mitani Yuuki
+1 Points
3. Kiba
4. Takishima Kei
5. Yuuri
+0 Points
6. Mitsuru Kirijo
6. C.C
6. Uchiha Sasuke
-1 Point
7. (General)
8. Tsukino Usagi
-2 Points
9. Presea
10. Aya-chan
BATTLE 02 RESULTS TALLIES
Sailor Scouts
1. +8 (+4) = +12 points
2. +11 (+8) = +19 points
3. -14 points
4. +2, -2 = 0 points
5. -5 points
Other Warriors
1. -7 points
2. -1, +6 = +5 points
3. +2, -2 = 0 points
4. -1, +1 = 0 points
5. -9, +3 = -6 points
6. +5 (+2) = +7 points
7. +5, -2 = +3 points
Link to voting table.
Icons were given +2 battle points for a priority 1 fave vote, +1 for a priority 2 fave vote, -2 for a priority 1 negative vote, -1 for a priority 2 negative vote, and +2 for an overall fave vote. Icons were then ranked based on number of battle points and organized into ranking quartiles, then given war points or had war points taken away based on that ranking. If any part of that is unclear, please let me know.
There were two eliminations during this battle.
If you would like your critiques, please leave a comment with the number of your icon and your avatar name. We will reply with a list of all the good/bad crits you received. ALL REPLIES WILL BE SCREENED, so if you do not get comments e-mailed to you, tell us and we will email the crits to you. Note: Some of the crits were VERY harsh. Do not ask for your critiques unless you're sure you can handle it. All crits will be kept 100% anonymous.