ROUND 03: PRELIM CH RESULTS
Gahhhh sorry these are so late. 8D; Sei and I just spent the last hour checking our tallies and there were lots of mistakes so it was good we did er to bring you accurate results~
ROUND 03 PRELIMINARY CHALLENGE PEOPLE'S CHOICES
Tales of The Abyss
#14 received 37 favorite points.
Community Icon
#18 received 35 favorite points.
Tear Grants's icon will be our new community icon! Unlike last round, this time we'll credit the character for anonymity purposes! But don't worry, the name will be revealed eventually, and we do mean the maker when we say Tear, of course. XD;
ROUND 03 PRELIMINARY CHALLENGE MOD'S CHOICES
Tales of the Abyss
#27
neonclover's commentary: Seems like amusing icons were all the rage this challenge. 8D This one made me snicker. I love the Phoenix Wright reference! The background chosen fits the image very nicely and helps with image focus a lot, too. :3 The image is nice and crisp, and the text is appropriately placed. My only nitpick would be that the notebook texture seems a little randomly placed, and other textures could have filled up space better - it's still a great icon though!
Community Icon
#24
almateria's commentary: This icon made me laugh when it was submitted! :3 Aside from the funny factor, the composition is nice and simple. The coloring is exceptional, and the cropping is focused. The image you chose was perfect, too! ♥
ROUND 03 PRELIMINARY CHALLENGE POINT STANDINGS
Listed in order of ranking! Scores shown are icon 1 + icon 2 = total score.
+4 points
1. Dist - +37, +18 = +55
2. Tear Grants - -1, +35 = +34
3. Jay - +28, +3 = +31
4. Chester Barklight - +16, +8 = +24
5. Zelos Wilder - +2, +20 = +22
6. Asch - +20, +1 = +21
7. Reala - +6, +13 = +19
+2 points
8. Sheena Fujibayashi - -5, +22 = +17
9. Shirley Fennes - +4, +12 = +16
10. Klarth F. Lester - +2, +13 = +15
11. Guy Cecil - +5, +9 = +14
12. Grune - +1, +6 = +7
13. Colette Brunel - +6, +0 = +6
14. Kyle Dunamis - +11, -6 = +5
15. Arietta - -6, +7 = +1
16. Luke fone Fabre - +2, -2 = +0
16. Leon Magnus - -1, +1 = +0
18. Pierre de Chaltier - +0, -3 = -2
19. Arche Klaine - +0, -11 = -11
20. Mithos Yggdrasill - +0, -13 = -13
21. Lloyd Irving - -18, -1 = -19
+1 point
22. Norma Beatty - -4, -22 = -26
23. Genis Sage - -19, -9 = -28
23. Anise Tatlin - -2, -26 = -28
25. Mieu - -30, +0 = -30
26. Keele Zeibel - -6, -39 = -45
27. Max - +1, -47 = -46
28. Iria Animi - -50, -4 = -54
A list of each individual icon's critique is up here (first table) and here (second table). ...And battle logs are up! Click on your avatar's name in the scores above to see your log. :3
Challenge 01 is up!
COMMENTS ARE SCREENED, so feel free to go crazy :D We'll unscreen any general comments.
ROUND 03 PRELIMINARY CHALLENGE PEOPLE'S CHOICES
Tales of The Abyss
#14 received 37 favorite points.
Community Icon
#18 received 35 favorite points.
Tear Grants's icon will be our new community icon! Unlike last round, this time we'll credit the character for anonymity purposes! But don't worry, the name will be revealed eventually, and we do mean the maker when we say Tear, of course. XD;
ROUND 03 PRELIMINARY CHALLENGE MOD'S CHOICES
Tales of the Abyss
#27
neonclover's commentary: Seems like amusing icons were all the rage this challenge. 8D This one made me snicker. I love the Phoenix Wright reference! The background chosen fits the image very nicely and helps with image focus a lot, too. :3 The image is nice and crisp, and the text is appropriately placed. My only nitpick would be that the notebook texture seems a little randomly placed, and other textures could have filled up space better - it's still a great icon though!
Community Icon
#24
almateria's commentary: This icon made me laugh when it was submitted! :3 Aside from the funny factor, the composition is nice and simple. The coloring is exceptional, and the cropping is focused. The image you chose was perfect, too! ♥
ROUND 03 PRELIMINARY CHALLENGE POINT STANDINGS
Listed in order of ranking! Scores shown are icon 1 + icon 2 = total score.
+4 points
1. Dist - +37, +18 = +55
2. Tear Grants - -1, +35 = +34
3. Jay - +28, +3 = +31
4. Chester Barklight - +16, +8 = +24
5. Zelos Wilder - +2, +20 = +22
6. Asch - +20, +1 = +21
7. Reala - +6, +13 = +19
+2 points
8. Sheena Fujibayashi - -5, +22 = +17
9. Shirley Fennes - +4, +12 = +16
10. Klarth F. Lester - +2, +13 = +15
11. Guy Cecil - +5, +9 = +14
12. Grune - +1, +6 = +7
13. Colette Brunel - +6, +0 = +6
14. Kyle Dunamis - +11, -6 = +5
15. Arietta - -6, +7 = +1
16. Luke fone Fabre - +2, -2 = +0
16. Leon Magnus - -1, +1 = +0
18. Pierre de Chaltier - +0, -3 = -2
19. Arche Klaine - +0, -11 = -11
20. Mithos Yggdrasill - +0, -13 = -13
21. Lloyd Irving - -18, -1 = -19
+1 point
22. Norma Beatty - -4, -22 = -26
23. Genis Sage - -19, -9 = -28
23. Anise Tatlin - -2, -26 = -28
25. Mieu - -30, +0 = -30
26. Keele Zeibel - -6, -39 = -45
27. Max - +1, -47 = -46
28. Iria Animi - -50, -4 = -54
A list of each individual icon's critique is up here (first table) and here (second table). ...And battle logs are up! Click on your avatar's name in the scores above to see your log. :3
Challenge 01 is up!
COMMENTS ARE SCREENED, so feel free to go crazy :D We'll unscreen any general comments.