OK, I'm still tired but more capable to form some thoughts. *g*
I love the whole concept behind this. And you can never go wrong with the Smashing Pumpkins. I personally don't think that Jack would just leave again on a whimp, only when he's really needed by the Doctor. And he would come back. But your interpretation is wonderful integrated into the vid. For me, it's a John/Jack-vid, but with a John who lives in the past and a Jack, that has moved on. There's still a connection and will probably always be, but it's not enough to just leave for it.
Things I liked:
- The title with the beautiful shot of the rift opening. I hope they will reuse this in the show for other things that come through - Around 0.10, when John and Jack 'walk towards each other' in tact with the music - The first "We must never be apart" and the summary of EotW till KKBB - 1:08, the mad rewind and slowing and making clips faster thing, COOL! - 1:15, "Perfect just like me" and Jack walking from the Morgue, again COOL! *g* - The "Lover in my bed, gun to my head", which fit perfectly - Around 1:37, the Jack-Gwen-Ianto-sequence (Even if I hated the whole engagement ring scene in the show *g*) - The fight sequence and then the part when John takes out the team, esp. Ianto=pretty, Jack=hungry - 2.50, Jack falling from the building and the timevortex - And the use of the shots of the Doctor from Family of Blood when he shows no mercy - 3:22, the three layers of the team, Jack/John and the TARDIS - 3:47, the team standing proud and the cuts to when John thought he brought them down. Go Team! (And it's great, that they finally have some team dynamic here too instead of only in SGA)
So, all in all. Loved it. Like always. It's great that you as a Jack/Gwen-shipper also included the Ianto scenes. But then, he's pretty. *g*
I'll probably never do another one, lol. *looks sad*
Also girl kissing. It can happen y/y? And Alien-kissing! And there'd better not too much kissing of other people as Ianto!
OK, I'm still tired but more capable to form some thoughts. *g* Thank you so much for you wonderful intelligent comments, always! I love hearing from you. :) *squish*
I personally don't think that Jack would just leave again on a whim, only when he's really needed by the Doctor. And he would come back. But your interpretation is wonderful integrated into the vid. I definitely don't think that when he does go on DW again, it won't be a huge secret, but I do think that there's always that chance, that if the Doctor came calling, Jack would run. We sort of agree on the main deal with him anyway.
For me, it's a John/Jack-vid, but with a John who lives in the past and a Jack, that has moved on. Yup. You are absolutely right. John represents this outside force that swoops in and complicates Jack's very complicated existence even more. But I always came back to john strutting about. ;)
Around 1:37, the Jack-Gwen-Ianto-sequence (Even if I hated the whole engagement ring scene in the show *g*) Hee! Yeah I kinda hated that as well. I sorta focused more on the wonderful way he touched her arm there, before he found the ring, lol.
The fight sequence and then the part when John takes out the team, esp. Ianto=pretty, Jack=hungry Yay! I'm so glad you mentioned this! I love how the song translated to him taking out each of them. :D
3:47, the team standing proud and the cuts to when John thought he brought them down. Go Team! (And it's great, that they finally have some team dynamic here too instead of only in SGA) And again I say YAY! It all worked out so perfectly, and they are now such a wonderful cohesive unit. I shall use my team icon. :D
It's great that you as a Jack/Gwen-shipper also included the Ianto scenes. But then, he's pretty. *g* Well he is indeed pretty, but I am not that shallow, lol. No, I include him because he is canon, and I am forever a slave to canon. :) Jack/Gwen is also canon, but more so from her perspective. ;) So every time I had a Gwen moment I followed it up with Ianto. Glad you enjoyed. :D
And Alien-kissing! And there'd better not too much kissing of other people as Ianto! Alien kissing! Yes pls! :D Lots and lots of kissing!
I love the whole concept behind this. And you can never go wrong with the Smashing Pumpkins. I personally don't think that Jack would just leave again on a whimp, only when he's really needed by the Doctor. And he would come back. But your interpretation is wonderful integrated into the vid.
For me, it's a John/Jack-vid, but with a John who lives in the past and a Jack, that has moved on. There's still a connection and will probably always be, but it's not enough to just leave for it.
Things I liked:
- The title with the beautiful shot of the rift opening. I hope they will reuse this in the show for other things that come through
- Around 0.10, when John and Jack 'walk towards each other' in tact with the music
- The first "We must never be apart" and the summary of EotW till KKBB
- 1:08, the mad rewind and slowing and making clips faster thing, COOL!
- 1:15, "Perfect just like me" and Jack walking from the Morgue, again COOL! *g*
- The "Lover in my bed, gun to my head", which fit perfectly
- Around 1:37, the Jack-Gwen-Ianto-sequence (Even if I hated the whole engagement ring scene in the show *g*)
- The fight sequence and then the part when John takes out the team, esp. Ianto=pretty, Jack=hungry
- 2.50, Jack falling from the building and the timevortex
- And the use of the shots of the Doctor from Family of Blood when he shows no mercy
- 3:22, the three layers of the team, Jack/John and the TARDIS
- 3:47, the team standing proud and the cuts to when John thought he brought them down. Go Team! (And it's great, that they finally have some team dynamic here too instead of only in SGA)
So, all in all. Loved it. Like always. It's great that you as a Jack/Gwen-shipper also included the Ianto scenes. But then, he's pretty. *g*
I'll probably never do another one, lol.
*looks sad*
Also girl kissing. It can happen y/y?
And Alien-kissing!
And there'd better not too much kissing of other people as Ianto!
Reply
Thank you so much for you wonderful intelligent comments, always! I love hearing from you. :) *squish*
I personally don't think that Jack would just leave again on a whim, only when he's really needed by the Doctor. And he would come back. But your interpretation is wonderful integrated into the vid.
I definitely don't think that when he does go on DW again, it won't be a huge secret, but I do think that there's always that chance, that if the Doctor came calling, Jack would run. We sort of agree on the main deal with him anyway.
For me, it's a John/Jack-vid, but with a John who lives in the past and a Jack, that has moved on.
Yup. You are absolutely right. John represents this outside force that swoops in and complicates Jack's very complicated existence even more. But I always came back to john strutting about. ;)
Around 1:37, the Jack-Gwen-Ianto-sequence (Even if I hated the whole engagement ring scene in the show *g*)
Hee! Yeah I kinda hated that as well. I sorta focused more on the wonderful way he touched her arm there, before he found the ring, lol.
The fight sequence and then the part when John takes out the team, esp. Ianto=pretty, Jack=hungry
Yay! I'm so glad you mentioned this! I love how the song translated to him taking out each of them. :D
3:47, the team standing proud and the cuts to when John thought he brought them down. Go Team! (And it's great, that they finally have some team dynamic here too instead of only in SGA)
And again I say YAY! It all worked out so perfectly, and they are now such a wonderful cohesive unit. I shall use my team icon. :D
It's great that you as a Jack/Gwen-shipper also included the Ianto scenes. But then, he's pretty. *g*
Well he is indeed pretty, but I am not that shallow, lol. No, I include him because he is canon, and I am forever a slave to canon. :) Jack/Gwen is also canon, but more so from her perspective. ;) So every time I had a Gwen moment I followed it up with Ianto. Glad you enjoyed. :D
And Alien-kissing!
And there'd better not too much kissing of other people as Ianto!
Alien kissing! Yes pls! :D Lots and lots of kissing!
Reply
Leave a comment