round02; challenge seven - voting

[minqie]

Thank you for all your entries, here we go :)

Vote in a comment to this post.

Vote for 3 (THREE) icons of lesser quality to be eliminated, and 2 (TWO) icons as your favorite for People's Choice awards. You are required to vote for 1 (ONE) set of favorite icons as well (e. g. Set A/B/C/D). For the elimination icons, please do judge based on overall technique and quality, not your personal preferences. We reserve the right to ask for further explanation or to void any vote we feel unfair. Reason for your favourite icon is optional, but you have to give reason for your eliminations.

Do not vote for your own icons for either category.

Anyone can vote. You do not have to be a participant or a member to vote.

If you have participated, you are encouraged to vote.

 12SET A

 34SET B

 56SET C

 78SET D


Voting format:

Eliminations:
#101 - The icon is too washed out.
#102 - The texture overpowers the subject of the icon.
#103 - The icon is blurry, a bit sharpening would be nice.

Favourites:
#104 - Awesome colouring, the cropping is original as well.
#105 -

Favourite set:
Set Z -

Eliminations:
# - REASON
# - REASON
# - REASON

Favourites:
# - REASON
# - REASON

Favourite set:
Set # - REASON

Voting ends on Sunday, March 21, 2010, 9pm (GMT+8).