Title
Adsense for Communities
Short, concise description of the idea
Adsense should be enabled for paid communities.
Full description of the idea
Adsense should be enabled for paid communities. I can't imagine why it wouldn't be.
An ordered list of benefits
- Same as for a paid personal account.
An ordered list of problems/issues involved
Right now, all ad revenue from comm activity is going to LJ. I see no reason for that to continue to be the case simply because of some misguided notion of group ownership of a comm that is, in fact, not group owned, and the inability to come up with a reasonable paradigm. After all, there is a paradigm in place for the control of the comm itself that works well in every istance of unilateral decision making. It's not as if a comm member can somehow wrest control of the comm from the owner. The system is equitable for purposes of control; ad revenue falls under that, unless you try to make it complicated.
And of course, the simplest way to get around the multiple moderator situation is to at least enable the functionality on any community that has only one owner/mod. Many people set up comms that do not have multiple mods and do not allow posting by members. Should the adsense functionality be restricted for them simply because some people operate their comms in a different way?
Reply
Reply
I think my main problem is that all of a sudden the friendly community I like to post in is making money off me. And it's not like visiting someone's adSense-d journal because I can block ads if I want. You're making the community into a mini LJ - using my content to make you money to use for your unclear purposes that I may well not agree with. Now obviously I'm on LJ right now, posting, so I know I go along with that, but that doesn't mean I want to see more of it. Yes, I could not post in that community, but then I would have to find a new 'home' and would suddenly have a lot of old content that I would have to go track down all over the site and delete not to participate.
Also, as a paid user not opted in to adSense, I might not even realise that the community (and my posts in it) had been monetized. How does that work? Does every member of the community get an email when someone flips that switch or would I just go on un-notified?
I also think there'd be a lot of drama. "The mod of $fandomcommunityx is using money from our fic posts to purchase hookers and blow! They said they'd use it on a mirror site and cupcakes :(".
Reply
I'd MUCH rather see money being collected anyway end up in the pocket of the people who go out of their way to organize spaces and activities for other people to utilize and enjoy than to see it accrue to some corporate entity. If they want to spend it on hookers and blow, so what? If I were that bothered by the whole notion of ad revenue, I'd buy a paid account.
This is beyond the fact that there are many comms that are moderated, and not open to member posting, and to which ad income could be meaningful, as in the case of fandom newsletters that take a whole HELL of a lot of effort on the part of the editors. I can't imagine begrudging them the income that is being collected ANYWAY.
Reply
On the other hand, LiveJournal is the corporate entity expected to implement this, and it might be against their financial interests to do so, so why would they?
Unlike personal journals, paid communities don't have many extra useful features. So, in that case, it'd only make sense to pay for a community to put ads on it if the ads gave more revenue than the cost of a paid account.
Except if LJ lets people who buy paid communities get that ad revenue instead, it means that there is now an incentive for the most popular communities that make the most ad revenue to go paid and then LJ gets less than it did before. (Also keep in mind that the ad networks LJ uses makes more money than Google AdSense does, or else they'd be using Google AdSense more instead.)
Now, it's possible that the mechanics don't actually work out like that, or that LJ would implement it just out of the "good of their heart" or something, but I wouldn't be surprised if that's another reason for communities to not get to hook up their own AdSense.
(An argument for doing it, I suppose, is that it gives good community maintainers an incentive to keep their communities active and healthy, but it's sort of weak in the face of cold hard cash.)
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment