(Untitled)

Feb 14, 2008 14:00

I saw the film for the third time last night and the more I see it the more I wonder...

(Content behind the cut contains spoilers!)

If Sweeney hadn't discovered his wife's body what would have become of him and Mrs Lovett?
If he hadn't have discovered his wife's body he obviously wouldn't have killed Mrs Lovett because the only reason he did was ( Read more... )

movie discussion

Leave a comment

zoe_df February 14 2008, 16:28:58 UTC
Anthony needed to learn not to run in shouting 'Mr Todd!' haha.
Just before he ran in Sweeney & Mrs Lovett seemed to move closer, they were making eye contact and it really did look like they were going to kiss. Like she said they might not have ended up how he remembered love or how she dreamed they would but they could at least have something together. They could use the money to move away from London & all the negative memories there. Plus Sweeney would have got his revenge. I think he was coming to terms with the fact he may never know his daughter and I think he would have been able to cope had he known she was definately free of the judge. Her being with Anthony was a lot better than her being the judge's property.

They're interesting fic ideas that both you and your other half have come up with!

If he hadn't have killed Lucy I highly doubt he could have gone back to how it used to be. False imprisonment had changed him, he was now a serial killer and she was mentally unwell after the break up of her family and the rape she experienced. Like Johanna said, the ghosts would never go away. It wouldn't have worked out and in a way Mrs Lovett did him a favour. Him believing she was dead was probably easier than having to deal with her in her ill beggar state. Mrs Lovett was more suited to the new him as she was equally as involved in his acts - she didn't kill but she helped dispose of the bodies in a gruesome way.

Reply

rose_cain February 19 2008, 17:21:12 UTC
"Maybe not like I dreamed - maybe not like you remember" - aaargh! I seriously and genuinely used that line on my ex (ish)the other day!
I hate Anthony and wanted to smack him in his silly teeth at that point!
Sorry, that was mature wasn't it?!

Reply


Leave a comment

Up