FIC: "Three's A Crowd"
TITLE: "Three's A Crowd"
AUTHOR: starky_cooper
PAIRING: Sheldon/Penny/Leonard
FANDOM: The Big Bang Theory
RATING: NC-17
WARNINGS: Graphic Sex
WORD COUNT: 5,758
NOTES: This is an old story written for Paradox Kink Meme. Prompt: Leonard and Penny are still dating, but they bring Sheldon in for an experiment. Leonard soon discovers that he's being excluded from the threesome, and starts to call the shots and watches Sheldon and Penny do what he says.
“Oh wow…” Leonard rolled to his side, completely exhausted and sated.
Penny giggled as she covered herself with the comforter, desperately trying not to roll her eyes. She’s become accustom to Leonard’s over zealous gratitude, his constant thanks and whatnot after sex.
“Can I ask you something?” Leonard propped himself on his elbow, looking down at Penny.
“Sweetie you just did.” Penny grinned cheekily.
“Ok Sheldon…” Leonard shook his head. “Ok seriously…what are your…umm…”
“What is it Leonard?” Penny sat up, looking at Leonard expectantly.
“Oh never mind. It was a silly question anyways. Not important.”
“Leonard…” Penny gave him a stern look. “Just ask me.”
“What are your fantasies?”
“As in sexually?”
“Yes.” Leonard looked down in embarrassment at Penny’s perplex look.
Giving the question some thought, Penny flushed hotly. She squeezed her thighs together trying to relieve some of the pressure that started to build rapidly at just the thought of what she’d love to do but knows she never will. She couldn’t tell Leonard what she was thinking. Just because he asked doesn’t necessarily mean that he wants to partake in her fantasies. She knows how Leonard is, he would never. Especially with his jealous nature.
Leonard noticed Penny’s reaction to the question. At first he was just curious, if she choose not to answer that was fine. But now, since she seemed about ready to fall apart at just the thought of her own fantasy, he desperately needs to know.
“Penny if you’re uncomfortable you don’t have to answer. We can just drop it. Or if you’re afraid that I’ll judge you, I swear I won’t.”
“Iwantathreesome…” Penny answered in a rush of words.
“Threesome?” Leonard grinned at the idea. He’s all for a threesome. What guy wouldn’t be? He’d love to see his girlfriend with another girl. That’s the ultimate male fantasy.
“Leonard it’s not what you’re thinking.”
Leonard furrowed his brows, squinted and tilted his head in confusion. Typical Leonard look, Penny couldn’t help but think. With a deep breath, Penny then explained what genders she wanted in her threesome, but more importantly, who she wanted.
*~~~~*~~~~*~~~~*
Today was the day. If they wanted their plan to be successful, they had to act today. It was the only logical day to do it.
They were both a bundle of nerves. Leonard couldn’t believe he agreed to it. But let’s face it, he was a sucker when it came to Penny. He’d do anything for her if it pleased her greatly. And this was something that went above and beyond that. The way her eyes lit up and her smile shined brightly in his dark bedroom, he knew she wanted this badly. And honestly he wasn’t surprised in the least. What did surprise him was that he didn’t see it sooner.
“Ok strip.” Penny tapped Leonard on the shoulder.
“I dunno Penny…do you really think this is going to work?”
“No I don’t, but that doesn’t mean I don’t want to try. Now strip.”
Right there in the middle of the living room of his and Sheldon’s apartment, Leonard stripped down to his boxers.
“Ok I don’t understand, why do I have to be the first person Sheldon sees and practically naked at that? I mean it’s not like he’s going to be attracted to me.”
“Do we really know that Leonard?”
Penny grinned sheepishly then dumped Leonard’s clothes on the couch to quickly disrobe down to her bra and panties.
“Wait a minute, Penny if that’s the case…”
“Oh calm down Leonard. You’re not Sheldon’s deal.”
“How can you be so sure? I mean…he’s never shown any sign…”
“Because he practically groped and ogled me when he helped me get dressed.”
“Wait what?”
“When I dislocated my shoulder and Sheldon came to my rescue.”
“Right, right…” Leonard tried not to get mad and jealous all over again about the situation.
“Ok Sheldon should be home any minute now.” Penny gathered the clothes and gave Leonard a lengthy kiss for encouragement. “See you in a bit.” Then disappeared down the hall.
Leonard paced the living room several times. He’s gone completely insane for agreeing to this. There was no way this was going to work. There wasn’t much to their plan to bed Sheldon; they should have thought it out more thoroughly. He went to the fridge to grab a bottle of water to quench his dry throat.
When he heard keys jingle outside his apartment door, Leonard nearly jumped out of his skin. Oh god he was going to be sick. Once their plan backfired which he knew it would, Leonard was certain that he was going to be permanently banished from his own home, or worst yet Sheldon would runaway back to Texas.
The minute Sheldon entered and dumped his keys into the bowl and his gaze landed on a half naked Leonard, Sheldon froze in his spot.
ABORT! ABORT! ABORT! Leonard screamed in his head.
“Leonard.” Sheldon nodded in his direction.
Sheldon’s seen Leonard in his boxers before but it was always accompanied with socks and an undershirt and right now he clearly had neither. Trying to dismiss Leonard’s lack of clothing, Sheldon took off his messenger bag and jacket and placed them on his desk.
“Sheldon!” Leonard squeaked in a somewhat singsong way.
Quickly Sheldon glanced around the apartment looking for damage to something that held great value to him. The last time Leonard said his name like that, Penny ruined his spot with green paint from a paintball gun. Not seeing anything Sheldon brought his gaze back to Leonard.
“Leonard might I ask as to why you’re in a state of undress and in our kitchen no less?”
“Oh I just came to get some water.”
“Leonard…I’m waiting.”
“Penny.” Leonard stated the obvious.
“Clearly.” Sheldon rolled his eyes. “Well since your presence is needed I’ll bid you a good night. I just ask that you and Penny please keep you frivolous activities at a low decibel.”
Sheldon walked down the hall to his room with Leonard in tow. The door to Leonard’s bedroom opened. There stood Penny in her matching red underwear. Sheldon gulped but couldn’t help but look Penny up and down. His eyes spotted The Flash’s logo on her boy shorts.
“Hey Sheldon.”
Sheldon turned crimson red, now looking everywhere else but at Penny. Penny, who had one arm resting the length of the doorway, the other twiddling a strand of curled hair with her hip popped out.
“Care to join us?”
Sheldon’s head snapped up so fast that he swore he got whiplash. Of all the absurd things Penny has ever asked or said to him…this was going too far.
“Penny I’m appalled that you would even ask such a question.”
“Oh lighten up Sheldon.” Penny smiled.
“Yeah, lighten up Sheldon.” Leonard repeated the words.
“Lighten up…”
“Yes, lighten up and come join us.” Penny stalked her way to Sheldon.
Sheldon slammed his back into his door as Penny advanced towards him. Penny stopped just breaths away in front of Sheldon.
“C’mon Sheldon. It’ll be fun.” Penny ran a finger down Sheldon’s chest.
“Oh…ha ha…I get it.” Sheldon nervously laughed. “Bazinga?” Sheldon looked between the two.
Penny bit her lip. “No…anything can happen Thursday.”
“Anything can happen…what?” Sheldon was baffled.
“It’s the third Thursday of the month.” Leonard chimed in.
“Which means anything and I mean…anything…can happen.” Penny pressed herself against Sheldon.
Sheldon’s red face turned pale. The look on his face was a classic deer caught in the headlights look. Baby deer, Penny thought. But unlike the advice she got then, Penny decided to be bolder. Grabbing one of Sheldon’s clinched fists, Penny rested it on her hip. The other she gently spread his fingers and slowly ran it along her side then placed it on her boob, the one Sheldon was already familiar with.
Sheldon looked at his loosely placed hand in wonderment. Standing on tiptoes Penny closed the distance and kissed Sheldon. Sheldon quickly broke the kiss and stared intensely at Penny.
“Please Sheldon…” Penny begged and captured his lips once again this time being more aggressive than before.
Sheldon’s grip tightened as he responded to the kiss. Penny moaned as she wrapped her arms around Sheldon’s neck. Leonard stared at his best friend/roommate and his girlfriend make out in awe. This was really going to happen. Holy crap, what was he supposed to do now? Yet another thing he really didn’t think through.
Penny was the one to break the kiss. With a smile Penny led the way back to Leonard’s bedroom. The two men looked at each other for a second, one silently asking for permission.
“Boys, are you coming?” Penny asked from the middle of the room, unclasping her bra and tossing it to the side.
With a shit eating grin towards Sheldon, Leonard replied, “Not yet…” Then proceeded to enter the room, and Sheldon willingly followed and closed the door behind him.
Sheldon licked his lips as he watched Leonard go up to Penny and ravishedly kiss her. Sheldon felt like the odd one out. He never thought he would be in this situation but more importantly he never thought he actually wanted to be in it to begin with. But there he stood, corrected, and waiting to be acknowledged once again.
Penny broke the kiss first and reached out a hand to Sheldon.
“C’mere.” Penny huskily beckoned.
With his head shyly downcast, Sheldon walked slowly to Penny.
“It’s ok Sheldon. Just relax.”
Penny led Sheldon to sit on the bed. Sheldon looked up as Penny straddled his lap. Penny softly kissed Sheldon’s face all over.
“God I’ve been so curious about you.” Penny quietly whispered in his ear. “I want to know what makes you lose control.” Penny licked his ear. “Just to get under your skin.” Penny lightly bit his ear.
Sheldon’s heartbeat was unbelievably fast as his breaths came in shorter puffs. His body was reacting strongly to Penny’s words.
“Penny…” Sheldon moaned.
Penny’s hips grinded against Sheldon’s three times.
“Penny…”
Grind. Grind. Grind.
“Penny…”
Grind. Grind. Grind.
With a blinding hunger Sheldon grabbed Penny’s face and kissed her with a passion he didn’t know he possessed. Penny moaned deeply from within and clawed desperately at Sheldon. Her hands immediately found the bottom of his shirts and started to lift them up. Sheldon raised his arms and broke the kiss to allow Penny to remove them.
“Leonard. Shoes.” Penny instructed.
Quickly Leonard followed orders, helping to undress Sheldon. Once Sheldon’s shirts were off, Penny stood and pushed Sheldon on his back then started to work on his belt. The moment the belt was off Penny made quick work for the pants. Sheldon held his breath when Penny teasingly brought the zipper down at an agonizing slow rate.
Finally, with help from Leonard, Penny had Sheldon stripped down to his boxers.
Penny leaned down and hooked her fingers into Sheldon’s boxers, placed a single kiss just below his belly button, giggled when she saw Sheldon’s muscles tighten then quickly rid him of his last bit of clothing.
Penny stood back and openly stared at Sheldon. This was probably the first time ever that Sheldon felt self-conscious. He had two sets of eyes staring at his naked form, neither saying a single word and for once he wanted to know the thoughts that were running through their minds.
Leonard stepped behind Penny and wrapped his arms around her waist. He began kissing her collarbone as he trailed a hand down her stomach. His finger toyed with the waistband. Sneaking a quick glance at Sheldon, who now sat up, Leonard saw that Sheldon had his eyes fixated on the movement of his hands. Looking back at his own hand, Leonard watched as it disappeared into Penny’s panties. Leonard was extremely surprised at how wet Penny was. None of them have really done anything yet and she was soaking wet. Leonard found Penny’s clit and rubbed it insistently.
“Oh god…” Penny moaned.
Her eyes threaten to close but she kept them open to watch Sheldon’s reaction. His knuckles were white from fisting the comforter tightly. He had a deep flush starting from his ears and his breathing was rapid.
“Sheldon…touch me…” Penny whimpered as Leonard sped up his ministrations.
“I…I-I’m not sure…what do to...first…?”
“Whatever you want sweetie…just…mmmm…” Penny couldn’t finish her sentence, she just rocked against Leonard’s hand.
Sheldon knelt down and hooked his fingers into Penny’s waistband. And just as Penny did to him, Sheldon did to her and removed her panties quickly. Sheldon sat on his heels and watched Leonard’s now visible hand rub circles on Penny’s clit.
“May I?” Sheldon looked up at the two.
“Ah…yeah…sure…” Leonard reluctantly removed his hand.
Sheldon reached up and entered a lone finger into Penny’s wetness. Penny lurched forward and braced herself on Sheldon’s shoulders for support. He added a second finger and started to penetrate faster.
“OH GOD!” Penny’s nails digged into Sheldon.
Not stopping his right hand, Sheldon removed Penny’s grip from his left shoulder then brought her right leg to rest on the now vacant shoulder. Leonard stared wide-eyed as Sheldon leaned forward and licked Penny’s clit. With one hand Penny held Sheldon’s head in place, rocking to his ministrations. With one last deep thrust of his fingers and a little nibble to her clit, Penny came hard.
“SHELDON!!!”
Penny struggled to stay up right on one leg. Had Leonard not been behind her, surely she would have fell from the sheer pleasure of the incredible orgasm Sheldon gave her.
“Oh my god…” Penny looked down and tugged lightly on Sheldon’s hair so that he looked up at her. “How the fuck did you know how to do that?”
With a wicked grin, Sheldon kissed Penny’s thigh before he removed it from his shoulder.
“I'm a physicist. I have a working knowledge of the entire universe and everything it contains. Anatomy being one of many.”
Leonard looked up in disbelief. He’s had more hands on experience with the female anatomy than Sheldon and he’s never made Penny or the other women he’s been with, orgasm/scream the way Sheldon did with Penny. It was utterly unbelievable the things that Dr. Sheldon Cooper excelled in.
“Well…” Penny contently giggled. “I know a thing or two about anatomy as well Dr. Cooper. Mind if I…demonstrate?”
Sheldon rose to his feet and brought Penny’s body flushed against his. Penny bit her lip when she felt Sheldon’s hard erection press into her abdomen. Sheldon raised his hand and rubbed his thumb over Penny’s bottom lip. Looking into Sheldon’s eyes, Penny snaked out her tongue and licked his thumb then sucked it into her mouth. Sheldon licked his lips to moisten them and inhaled deeply.
Not being able to hold on any longer, Penny forcefully pushed Sheldon onto the bed where she all but jumped on him. Sheldon groaned when he felt Penny’s wet center straddle his stomach. Leaning down Penny kissed Sheldon urgently. Sheldon gripped Penny’s hips and started rocking his hips. Penny bit Sheldon’s lip when she felt his cock rub against her ass.
Leonard stood there, hands tightly gripping his boxers, completely forgotten and totally disgusted. Disgusted because he couldn’t do anything. He came to the conclusion that Penny never really wanted a threesome, she just simply wanted Sheldon. Trying not to hurt his feelings Penny probably said threesome so that he would agree to it. Unsurprisingly he did and now he was excluded. He wanted to be mad, jealous even but he couldn’t. He was so incredibly turned on. He became so aroused watching the two. But it wasn’t fair. He needed some relief too.
“STOP!”
Penny and Sheldon stopped kissing and looked expectantly at Leonard.
“What?” Penny said through gritted teeth.
“I’ve come to realize that I no longer fit in this…equation.”
“Sweetie, I’m s…”
“No, no apologies…I know they will only be in vain. Anyway I’ve come up with a solution that will fix this little problem.” Leonard waited half a breath for any response.
“I call the shots.”
“Excuse me?” Penny questioned.
“As a compromise to letting you two have sex, I get to call the shots. I tell you what to do and how to do it, to my liking.”
Leonard walked over to his dresser and retrieved two items that he kept hidden from the couple on the bed.
“Sheldon you claim that you know anatomy.”
“It’s a fact not a claim.” Sheldon corrected.
“OK…it’s a fact that you know anatomy, my question is, do you know how to control said anatomy?”
“Well…umm…how do you mean?”
“Would you be able to control your own body when it’s simulated? Would you be able to hold it together when you are receiving the most amazing pleasure in your life? Are you really a Homo novus or just a regular homo sapien like the rest of us?”
“I…I…well…”
“I have the perfect experiment to find out.”
Leonard lifted his hands and let the contents slowly reveal themselves. Penny’s eyes lit up instantly. Leonard walked over to Penny and gave her the two silky materials. Penny squealed feeling the smoothness of the red scarves.
“Penny, tie Sheldon up to the bed.”
“Tie? What? No one is tying me up to anything.” Sheldon sat up, Penny still in his lap.
“Really? As a scientist I thought you liked experiments? Are you afraid of what the results might be? Are you afraid of being proven wrong?” Leonard challenged.
Sheldon glared at Leonard but scooted to rest his back against the headboard of the bed.
“Oh it’s junior rodeo on baby!” Penny exclaimed.
Leonard stood with his arms across his chest watching Penny safely and securely tie Sheldon’s wrists to the bed.
Sheldon tested his bindings. Penny’s skills of hog-tying were efficient. The tie wasn’t too tight to cut off circulation but tight enough that he wouldn’t be able to free himself. Sheldon watched as Penny admired her work, raw hunger evident in her eyes. His gaze then wandered to Leonard, who held his chin, contemplating their next move. Sheldon’s cock twitched at the prospects.
Penny sat on her heels, hands now resting on Sheldon’s thighs, lightly scraping her nails along them.
“What do you want me to do next Leonard?”
As Penny waited for orders, she had to admit to herself that she never anticipated the night’s events to turn out the way they have thus far. Truth be told she didn’t want a threesome, she just wanted Sheldon. She craved Sheldon. And now she has him where she wants him but with guidance from Leonard. Leonard, Penny laughed. She had no idea Leonard had it in him to be so…assertive, to be so commanding. That in itself turned her on.
“Stroke him. Just jerk Sheldon off.”
Sheldon gulped at Leonard’s request and stared wide-eyed as Penny inched her hand closer and closer to his hard erection. Sheldon sucked in a lung full of air when he felt the barest of touches as Penny’s fingers lightly enclosed him. Sheldon released a faint moan at the first stroke. Once a steady rhythm was established Sheldon rocked himself with Penny’s motion.
“Go faster.” Leonard ordered.
Penny sped up, locking eyes with Sheldon. Sheldon felt the pleasure building up in the pit of his stomach. His abdominal muscles tighten and his toes curled. Sheldon tilted his head back with eyes closed, willing his body to stay in control and not to succumb to the pleasure it desired.
“Faster.”
Sheldon held his bottom lip between his teeth. He averted his eyes from Penny’s. The look of raw lust in her eyes was just too much to handle. His eyes couldn’t focus on one thing; they kept wandering back to Penny and what she was doing to him. Then Sheldon made the mistake of landing his eyes on Penny’s naked breasts. They bounced deliciously along with her fast motions on his cock. His body started shaking. He could taste his pleasure begging to come out.
“Stop.”
Penny stopped immediately and released Sheldon from her grasp. Sheldon dropped his head forward, trying to regain control on his breathing. The task was beyond possible; every ounce of energy he has was rushing towards his cock. Release was the only thing that was on his mind.
“Now…” Leonard rubbed his hands together. “I think its high time Sheldon gets his first blowjob. What do you think Sheldon?”
Sheldon’s head snapped up. He wasn’t sure if he could endure the feel of Penny’s beautiful lips wrapped snuggly around him. Sheldon closed his eyes, he couldn’t watch no matter how desperately he wanted to. He has a point to prove and his resolve was rapidly coming undone and watching would most definitely set it off.
Penny placed a soft kiss to Sheldon’s tip. She licked her lips in preparation and tasted him on them. That little taste made her want more. Sticking her tongue out Penny licked Sheldon from base to tip. Once at the tip Penny sucked him into her mouth.
“Oh good lord…” Sheldon panted.
Penny slowly took Sheldon in inch by inch. Sheldon clenched and unclenched his fists. Absentmindedly he banged his head against the headboard. He was uncertain if the ringing in his ears came from that or from what Penny was doing. His senses were on overdrive, they all blended into one and he couldn’t pinpoint what sensation came from what or where.
“Penny I think Sheldon’s had enough teasing.”
Sheldon’s silent prayers were answered. He was on the edge of slipping into the abyss; he didn’t know how much longer he could last.
“Why don’t you show Sheldon what you can really do. Stop holding back.”
Sheldon looked down at Penny. Eyes intensely locked on one another, Penny took Sheldon’s full length in her mouth.
“SWEET JESUS!!” Sheldon cried out when he felt the head of his cock grasped by Penny’s throat.
Penny hollowed her cheeks and that’s when Sheldon started to thrash. Penny lifted her head until just the tip of Sheldon was between her lips. She licked the pre-cum that glistened out, causing more loud moans from Sheldon. Leonard urged Penny to quicken her pace and she obliged willingly.
“Oh god…Penny…Penny…ahhh…Penny.”
Sheldon’s head moved side to side, his hips up and down. Penny’s mouth felt so good. It was too much and yet not enough. The logic wasn’t sound but he couldn’t help it. It was the only way he could describe it.
Penny relished in Sheldon’s groans. They were so un-Sheldon like, so foreign to her ears that she did anything to make sure he kept on making those sounds. With her left hand Penny brought it to Sheldon’s neglected balls and gave them a firm squeeze.
“SHIT!”
Penny almost came right on the spot from hearing Sheldon curse. Never has she ever heard Sheldon curse, it was so…hot! Now there’s no way she would ever be able to hear Sheldon curse without getting aroused. With her free hand, Penny slid it down her stomach to rub her throbbing clit. She desperately needed relief. Hearing Sheldon cuss and moan, and with him practically fucking her mouth, she needed some proper attention.
Sheldon watched as Penny started fingering herself. The sight of Penny pleasuring herself plus the continuing bobbing of her head was over simulating Sheldon’s crazed senses. His orgasm was right there, he could feel it, he could taste it and he was going to let himself go. The delicious torture had to stop. He needed to admit defeat. All he needed was a little more…
“STOP!” Leonard commanded.
“FUCK!!” Sheldon yelled as Penny’s lips slipped away from his body. “GOD DAMN IT LEONARD!”
Penny and Leonard started at Sheldon in disbelief, never have they witnessed Sheldon burst out like that.
“If, if…I could blow your head up with…my, my mind…you would be lying lifelessly on the floor Leonard Hofstadter!”
Leonard burst in hysterics; the sound was pure evil to Sheldon.
“Getting a little frustrated are we?” Leonard teased; Sheldon just huffed. “Why didn’t you just let go?”
Sheldon looked down he wasn’t going to admit to Leonard that he almost let go, that he wanted to let go.
“Well you can thank Penny for the abrupt stop.” Leonard stated when Sheldon stayed silent.
Penny looked at Leonard in confusion. Leonard stepped towards the bed and grabbed Penny’s right hand.
“I don’t believe I said you could pleasure yourself.”
Penny’s mouth gaped open; she looked between the two men.
“I…god I couldn’t help myself. I’m sorry…just tell us what to do next.”
Leonard was proud of himself. He’s not quite sure how he did it, but he managed to hold a great power over the two. It was a nice boost of confidence. Leonard could feel the weight of their stare, they begged for the next move. Penny’s hand was still in his grasp, eyeing Sheldon; Leonard brought her fingers to his lips and gave them a little lick. The two gasped.
“You taste good Penny. So sweet. Doesn’t she taste good Sheldon?” Leonard looked at Sheldon as he continued to lap at Penny’s fingers. “I bet you’d like another taste. Isn’t Penny’s arousal delicious.”
The words were obscene to Sheldon but they spoke the truth. If he concentrated hard enough, he could still taste her on his tongue. His raging hormones were driving him crazy; he’d give anything to taste Penny again.
Leonard tugged Penny’s hand and pressed her fingers against Sheldon’s lips. The instant her fingers were there, Sheldon greedily took them into his mouth, sucking them clean. Penny moaned, squeezing her thighs together, the pressure between her legs was getting unbearable.
“Leonard…please…” Penny begged. “I need…god…please…”
“What do you want Penny?” He knew what she wanted but Leonard wanted to hear Penny say it.
“I want…” Penny looked into Sheldon’s now dark blue eyes. “Sheldon. I want Sheldon.”
“But what exactly is it that you want Penny? Say it.”
“I want to have sex with Sheldon. God I need to fuck him so bad…it hurts.”
Leonard sat at the very edge of the bed and nodded at Penny. Penny jumped into Sheldon’s lap, kissed him hungrily then quickly sank down on his throbbing cock.
“OH GOD!” They both screamed in unison.
Penny sat there, adjusting to Sheldon’s size; he was a magnificent fit. He stretched her wonderfully.
“Penny…” Sheldon whimpered. “Release my hands…I need to touch you.”
Penny went to reach for one of Sheldon’s tied hands.
“Oh I don’t think so.” Leonard piped in.
“Damn you Leonard Hofstadter!”
Sheldon gave Leonard an evil glare and in return Leonard gave Sheldon a wicked grin.
“Holy…mmm…Penny…” Sheldon moaned when he felt Penny’s walls tighten around him.
“Focus Dr. Cooper.” Penny teased as she began to rock her hips.
Sheldon quickly found Penny’s rhythm. Being inside Penny, feeling her wet heat, there simply weren’t any appropriate words to describe it. He would gladly stay lost in her forever.
Penny gripped one of Sheldon’s shoulders and the other held tightly onto the comforter beside her left thigh as she bounced up and down on Sheldon’s pulsating length. Penny tilted her head back and arched her back, creating a new angle to allow Sheldon to go deeper.
“CHRIST!”
Sheldon pulled at his restraints, the new angle was total bliss but it left Sheldon in agony. He needed to touch Penny everywhere. He longed to take her breasts into his hands and into his mouth. He wanted to kiss, lick, suck and bite her nipples that were begging for attention.
The pressure was building again. It was there. Sweet release was coming. Penny and Sheldon frantically rocked against each other.
“Stop.” This time Leonard didn’t hold back his laughter.
“That’s three strikes Leonard.”
“I swear I’m going to kill you.”
Leonard’s laughter roared even louder at their empty threats.
“Penny get off.”
“For Christ’s sake that’s what I’ve been trying to do.”
“No seriously get off of Sheldon.”
“You’re a man that truly has a death wish.”
Painfully Penny removed herself from Sheldon. Leonard got off the bed and walked over to one of Sheldon’s tied wrists. Gently Leonard freed Sheldon. Sheldon massaged each wrist and examined the red marks that didn’t fade away instantly. Penny took a wrist in her hand and placed a kiss on Sheldon’s pulse point that raced wildly. Leonard went back to sitting at the end of the bed.
“Penny face me, on your hands and knees.” Leonard instructed.
If Penny’s pupils could dilate any more, if her body could flush any more, if her pussy could become any wetter, they all would have done so at Leonard’s instructions. She knew what he was asking for and god she couldn’t wait.
Penny threw her hair to one side and looked over her shoulder to Sheldon, who just sat there contemplating what was going on.
“Fuck me Sheldon. Hard.”
Sheldon was taken back by Penny’s vulgar language. He looked at Leonard but only received a shrug. Getting up on his knees, Sheldon held his cock in one hand and ran it along Penny’s wet slit. Penny thrust her hips back, wanting Sheldon inside her once again. Sheldon placed himself at Penny’s entrance and slammed into her.
All three moaned. Penny watched as Leonard finally removed his boxers. Leonard was just as aroused as she and Sheldon were.
Sheldon began to thrust relentlessly. He’s never been so aroused in his entire life nor for this long period of time for that matter. His grip on Penny’s hips was tight, bound to leave a mark.
“Sheldon…” Penny breathlessly moaned. “Harder…mmm…deeper.”
“Sheldon…hair…Penny’s hair.” Leonard stroked himself, watching the two.
Sheldon didn’t know what order to take. He didn’t know what Leonard meant by Penny’s hair but he couldn’t formulate the question out loud. His brain was mush and it only had one thing on its mind.
Sheldon looked down where his and Penny’s bodies were joined together. The image of him thrusting in and out of Penny will forever be imprinted in his mind. His eyes slowly wandered up to Penny’s “soup” tattoo and with one finger Sheldon traced it. The action received a giggle/moan from Penny. Sheldon then flatten his palm against Penny’s lower back. That hand inched its way up to Penny’s neck. From there Sheldon ran his fingers through Penny’s hair. Penny groaned loudly when Sheldon suddenly fisted her hair and gently tugged on it. With another slight pull Penny had her back pressed against Sheldon’s chest.
Penny turned her head and sought out Sheldon’s lips. Another pull and Sheldon angled Penny’s head to properly kiss her deeply.
“God Sheldon…I’m almost there.”
“Me too…” Sheldon licked Penny’s neck then bit down.
“OHHHH!”
Penny forced her hips harder into Sheldon’s. Her left hand went behind and grabbed Sheldon’s ass.
“Touch her Sheldon.” Leonard started pumping faster.
The hand that once resided in Penny’s hair went and grabbed firmly onto her boob. His fingers pinched and pulled at its nipple.
“Mmmm…”
With his hips slamming madly into Penny’s, Sheldon reached over and pressed his thumb strongly on Penny’s clit.
“AHHH…”
“Not yet Penny.” Leonard requested.
“I can’t…don’t stop…please Sheldon …God Leonard…”
With her free hand, Penny held onto Sheldon’s hand that pressed hard onto her clit. Her and Sheldon’s movements were perfectly in sync. Penny couldn’t stand it any longer.
“SHELDON! FUCK!”
Penny’s climax hit her hard. The ripples of pleasure were endless. Penny slumped forward, her body exhausted but Sheldon still continued to pump into her.
“Sheldon…let go.”
Despite Penny’s spasming walls creating a vice like grip, Sheldon was determined to last a little longer. Quickly pulling out, Sheldon flipped Penny onto her back. Before he re-entered her, Sheldon threw Penny’s left leg over his shoulder. One hand held onto Penny’s thigh for dear life and the other held the comforter beside Penny’s head.
Sheldon pressed his forehead against Penny’s; their short breaths of air mingling together. Penny didn’t think it was possible but another powerful orgasm struck her, with Sheldon’s name on her lips.
“PENNY!!” Penny’s pleasure laced screams was Sheldon’s and Leonard’s undoing.
Exhausted and totally spent, Sheldon collapsed on top of Penny.
The room was quiet, the only thing that could be heard was their breathing. Sheldon rolled to Penny’s side and quickly Penny pressed her back against his chest needing to still be close to him. She looked over to Leonard and beckoned him to her. He laid chest to chest with her. Nobody said a word for a few minutes. Penny’s giggling then broke the silence.
“How are we going to top the next ‘Anything can happen Thursday’?”
“We have to wait that long?” Sheldon questioned in disbelief.
“Well I guess you’re a regular Homo sapien after all Sheldon. Who knew?” Penny’s laughter roared the room.
AUTHOR: starky_cooper
PAIRING: Sheldon/Penny/Leonard
FANDOM: The Big Bang Theory
RATING: NC-17
WARNINGS: Graphic Sex
WORD COUNT: 5,758
NOTES: This is an old story written for Paradox Kink Meme. Prompt: Leonard and Penny are still dating, but they bring Sheldon in for an experiment. Leonard soon discovers that he's being excluded from the threesome, and starts to call the shots and watches Sheldon and Penny do what he says.
“Oh wow…” Leonard rolled to his side, completely exhausted and sated.
Penny giggled as she covered herself with the comforter, desperately trying not to roll her eyes. She’s become accustom to Leonard’s over zealous gratitude, his constant thanks and whatnot after sex.
“Can I ask you something?” Leonard propped himself on his elbow, looking down at Penny.
“Sweetie you just did.” Penny grinned cheekily.
“Ok Sheldon…” Leonard shook his head. “Ok seriously…what are your…umm…”
“What is it Leonard?” Penny sat up, looking at Leonard expectantly.
“Oh never mind. It was a silly question anyways. Not important.”
“Leonard…” Penny gave him a stern look. “Just ask me.”
“What are your fantasies?”
“As in sexually?”
“Yes.” Leonard looked down in embarrassment at Penny’s perplex look.
Giving the question some thought, Penny flushed hotly. She squeezed her thighs together trying to relieve some of the pressure that started to build rapidly at just the thought of what she’d love to do but knows she never will. She couldn’t tell Leonard what she was thinking. Just because he asked doesn’t necessarily mean that he wants to partake in her fantasies. She knows how Leonard is, he would never. Especially with his jealous nature.
Leonard noticed Penny’s reaction to the question. At first he was just curious, if she choose not to answer that was fine. But now, since she seemed about ready to fall apart at just the thought of her own fantasy, he desperately needs to know.
“Penny if you’re uncomfortable you don’t have to answer. We can just drop it. Or if you’re afraid that I’ll judge you, I swear I won’t.”
“Iwantathreesome…” Penny answered in a rush of words.
“Threesome?” Leonard grinned at the idea. He’s all for a threesome. What guy wouldn’t be? He’d love to see his girlfriend with another girl. That’s the ultimate male fantasy.
“Leonard it’s not what you’re thinking.”
Leonard furrowed his brows, squinted and tilted his head in confusion. Typical Leonard look, Penny couldn’t help but think. With a deep breath, Penny then explained what genders she wanted in her threesome, but more importantly, who she wanted.
*~~~~*~~~~*~~~~*
Today was the day. If they wanted their plan to be successful, they had to act today. It was the only logical day to do it.
They were both a bundle of nerves. Leonard couldn’t believe he agreed to it. But let’s face it, he was a sucker when it came to Penny. He’d do anything for her if it pleased her greatly. And this was something that went above and beyond that. The way her eyes lit up and her smile shined brightly in his dark bedroom, he knew she wanted this badly. And honestly he wasn’t surprised in the least. What did surprise him was that he didn’t see it sooner.
“Ok strip.” Penny tapped Leonard on the shoulder.
“I dunno Penny…do you really think this is going to work?”
“No I don’t, but that doesn’t mean I don’t want to try. Now strip.”
Right there in the middle of the living room of his and Sheldon’s apartment, Leonard stripped down to his boxers.
“Ok I don’t understand, why do I have to be the first person Sheldon sees and practically naked at that? I mean it’s not like he’s going to be attracted to me.”
“Do we really know that Leonard?”
Penny grinned sheepishly then dumped Leonard’s clothes on the couch to quickly disrobe down to her bra and panties.
“Wait a minute, Penny if that’s the case…”
“Oh calm down Leonard. You’re not Sheldon’s deal.”
“How can you be so sure? I mean…he’s never shown any sign…”
“Because he practically groped and ogled me when he helped me get dressed.”
“Wait what?”
“When I dislocated my shoulder and Sheldon came to my rescue.”
“Right, right…” Leonard tried not to get mad and jealous all over again about the situation.
“Ok Sheldon should be home any minute now.” Penny gathered the clothes and gave Leonard a lengthy kiss for encouragement. “See you in a bit.” Then disappeared down the hall.
Leonard paced the living room several times. He’s gone completely insane for agreeing to this. There was no way this was going to work. There wasn’t much to their plan to bed Sheldon; they should have thought it out more thoroughly. He went to the fridge to grab a bottle of water to quench his dry throat.
When he heard keys jingle outside his apartment door, Leonard nearly jumped out of his skin. Oh god he was going to be sick. Once their plan backfired which he knew it would, Leonard was certain that he was going to be permanently banished from his own home, or worst yet Sheldon would runaway back to Texas.
The minute Sheldon entered and dumped his keys into the bowl and his gaze landed on a half naked Leonard, Sheldon froze in his spot.
ABORT! ABORT! ABORT! Leonard screamed in his head.
“Leonard.” Sheldon nodded in his direction.
Sheldon’s seen Leonard in his boxers before but it was always accompanied with socks and an undershirt and right now he clearly had neither. Trying to dismiss Leonard’s lack of clothing, Sheldon took off his messenger bag and jacket and placed them on his desk.
“Sheldon!” Leonard squeaked in a somewhat singsong way.
Quickly Sheldon glanced around the apartment looking for damage to something that held great value to him. The last time Leonard said his name like that, Penny ruined his spot with green paint from a paintball gun. Not seeing anything Sheldon brought his gaze back to Leonard.
“Leonard might I ask as to why you’re in a state of undress and in our kitchen no less?”
“Oh I just came to get some water.”
“Leonard…I’m waiting.”
“Penny.” Leonard stated the obvious.
“Clearly.” Sheldon rolled his eyes. “Well since your presence is needed I’ll bid you a good night. I just ask that you and Penny please keep you frivolous activities at a low decibel.”
Sheldon walked down the hall to his room with Leonard in tow. The door to Leonard’s bedroom opened. There stood Penny in her matching red underwear. Sheldon gulped but couldn’t help but look Penny up and down. His eyes spotted The Flash’s logo on her boy shorts.
“Hey Sheldon.”
Sheldon turned crimson red, now looking everywhere else but at Penny. Penny, who had one arm resting the length of the doorway, the other twiddling a strand of curled hair with her hip popped out.
“Care to join us?”
Sheldon’s head snapped up so fast that he swore he got whiplash. Of all the absurd things Penny has ever asked or said to him…this was going too far.
“Penny I’m appalled that you would even ask such a question.”
“Oh lighten up Sheldon.” Penny smiled.
“Yeah, lighten up Sheldon.” Leonard repeated the words.
“Lighten up…”
“Yes, lighten up and come join us.” Penny stalked her way to Sheldon.
Sheldon slammed his back into his door as Penny advanced towards him. Penny stopped just breaths away in front of Sheldon.
“C’mon Sheldon. It’ll be fun.” Penny ran a finger down Sheldon’s chest.
“Oh…ha ha…I get it.” Sheldon nervously laughed. “Bazinga?” Sheldon looked between the two.
Penny bit her lip. “No…anything can happen Thursday.”
“Anything can happen…what?” Sheldon was baffled.
“It’s the third Thursday of the month.” Leonard chimed in.
“Which means anything and I mean…anything…can happen.” Penny pressed herself against Sheldon.
Sheldon’s red face turned pale. The look on his face was a classic deer caught in the headlights look. Baby deer, Penny thought. But unlike the advice she got then, Penny decided to be bolder. Grabbing one of Sheldon’s clinched fists, Penny rested it on her hip. The other she gently spread his fingers and slowly ran it along her side then placed it on her boob, the one Sheldon was already familiar with.
Sheldon looked at his loosely placed hand in wonderment. Standing on tiptoes Penny closed the distance and kissed Sheldon. Sheldon quickly broke the kiss and stared intensely at Penny.
“Please Sheldon…” Penny begged and captured his lips once again this time being more aggressive than before.
Sheldon’s grip tightened as he responded to the kiss. Penny moaned as she wrapped her arms around Sheldon’s neck. Leonard stared at his best friend/roommate and his girlfriend make out in awe. This was really going to happen. Holy crap, what was he supposed to do now? Yet another thing he really didn’t think through.
Penny was the one to break the kiss. With a smile Penny led the way back to Leonard’s bedroom. The two men looked at each other for a second, one silently asking for permission.
“Boys, are you coming?” Penny asked from the middle of the room, unclasping her bra and tossing it to the side.
With a shit eating grin towards Sheldon, Leonard replied, “Not yet…” Then proceeded to enter the room, and Sheldon willingly followed and closed the door behind him.
Sheldon licked his lips as he watched Leonard go up to Penny and ravishedly kiss her. Sheldon felt like the odd one out. He never thought he would be in this situation but more importantly he never thought he actually wanted to be in it to begin with. But there he stood, corrected, and waiting to be acknowledged once again.
Penny broke the kiss first and reached out a hand to Sheldon.
“C’mere.” Penny huskily beckoned.
With his head shyly downcast, Sheldon walked slowly to Penny.
“It’s ok Sheldon. Just relax.”
Penny led Sheldon to sit on the bed. Sheldon looked up as Penny straddled his lap. Penny softly kissed Sheldon’s face all over.
“God I’ve been so curious about you.” Penny quietly whispered in his ear. “I want to know what makes you lose control.” Penny licked his ear. “Just to get under your skin.” Penny lightly bit his ear.
Sheldon’s heartbeat was unbelievably fast as his breaths came in shorter puffs. His body was reacting strongly to Penny’s words.
“Penny…” Sheldon moaned.
Penny’s hips grinded against Sheldon’s three times.
“Penny…”
Grind. Grind. Grind.
“Penny…”
Grind. Grind. Grind.
With a blinding hunger Sheldon grabbed Penny’s face and kissed her with a passion he didn’t know he possessed. Penny moaned deeply from within and clawed desperately at Sheldon. Her hands immediately found the bottom of his shirts and started to lift them up. Sheldon raised his arms and broke the kiss to allow Penny to remove them.
“Leonard. Shoes.” Penny instructed.
Quickly Leonard followed orders, helping to undress Sheldon. Once Sheldon’s shirts were off, Penny stood and pushed Sheldon on his back then started to work on his belt. The moment the belt was off Penny made quick work for the pants. Sheldon held his breath when Penny teasingly brought the zipper down at an agonizing slow rate.
Finally, with help from Leonard, Penny had Sheldon stripped down to his boxers.
Penny leaned down and hooked her fingers into Sheldon’s boxers, placed a single kiss just below his belly button, giggled when she saw Sheldon’s muscles tighten then quickly rid him of his last bit of clothing.
Penny stood back and openly stared at Sheldon. This was probably the first time ever that Sheldon felt self-conscious. He had two sets of eyes staring at his naked form, neither saying a single word and for once he wanted to know the thoughts that were running through their minds.
Leonard stepped behind Penny and wrapped his arms around her waist. He began kissing her collarbone as he trailed a hand down her stomach. His finger toyed with the waistband. Sneaking a quick glance at Sheldon, who now sat up, Leonard saw that Sheldon had his eyes fixated on the movement of his hands. Looking back at his own hand, Leonard watched as it disappeared into Penny’s panties. Leonard was extremely surprised at how wet Penny was. None of them have really done anything yet and she was soaking wet. Leonard found Penny’s clit and rubbed it insistently.
“Oh god…” Penny moaned.
Her eyes threaten to close but she kept them open to watch Sheldon’s reaction. His knuckles were white from fisting the comforter tightly. He had a deep flush starting from his ears and his breathing was rapid.
“Sheldon…touch me…” Penny whimpered as Leonard sped up his ministrations.
“I…I-I’m not sure…what do to...first…?”
“Whatever you want sweetie…just…mmmm…” Penny couldn’t finish her sentence, she just rocked against Leonard’s hand.
Sheldon knelt down and hooked his fingers into Penny’s waistband. And just as Penny did to him, Sheldon did to her and removed her panties quickly. Sheldon sat on his heels and watched Leonard’s now visible hand rub circles on Penny’s clit.
“May I?” Sheldon looked up at the two.
“Ah…yeah…sure…” Leonard reluctantly removed his hand.
Sheldon reached up and entered a lone finger into Penny’s wetness. Penny lurched forward and braced herself on Sheldon’s shoulders for support. He added a second finger and started to penetrate faster.
“OH GOD!” Penny’s nails digged into Sheldon.
Not stopping his right hand, Sheldon removed Penny’s grip from his left shoulder then brought her right leg to rest on the now vacant shoulder. Leonard stared wide-eyed as Sheldon leaned forward and licked Penny’s clit. With one hand Penny held Sheldon’s head in place, rocking to his ministrations. With one last deep thrust of his fingers and a little nibble to her clit, Penny came hard.
“SHELDON!!!”
Penny struggled to stay up right on one leg. Had Leonard not been behind her, surely she would have fell from the sheer pleasure of the incredible orgasm Sheldon gave her.
“Oh my god…” Penny looked down and tugged lightly on Sheldon’s hair so that he looked up at her. “How the fuck did you know how to do that?”
With a wicked grin, Sheldon kissed Penny’s thigh before he removed it from his shoulder.
“I'm a physicist. I have a working knowledge of the entire universe and everything it contains. Anatomy being one of many.”
Leonard looked up in disbelief. He’s had more hands on experience with the female anatomy than Sheldon and he’s never made Penny or the other women he’s been with, orgasm/scream the way Sheldon did with Penny. It was utterly unbelievable the things that Dr. Sheldon Cooper excelled in.
“Well…” Penny contently giggled. “I know a thing or two about anatomy as well Dr. Cooper. Mind if I…demonstrate?”
Sheldon rose to his feet and brought Penny’s body flushed against his. Penny bit her lip when she felt Sheldon’s hard erection press into her abdomen. Sheldon raised his hand and rubbed his thumb over Penny’s bottom lip. Looking into Sheldon’s eyes, Penny snaked out her tongue and licked his thumb then sucked it into her mouth. Sheldon licked his lips to moisten them and inhaled deeply.
Not being able to hold on any longer, Penny forcefully pushed Sheldon onto the bed where she all but jumped on him. Sheldon groaned when he felt Penny’s wet center straddle his stomach. Leaning down Penny kissed Sheldon urgently. Sheldon gripped Penny’s hips and started rocking his hips. Penny bit Sheldon’s lip when she felt his cock rub against her ass.
Leonard stood there, hands tightly gripping his boxers, completely forgotten and totally disgusted. Disgusted because he couldn’t do anything. He came to the conclusion that Penny never really wanted a threesome, she just simply wanted Sheldon. Trying not to hurt his feelings Penny probably said threesome so that he would agree to it. Unsurprisingly he did and now he was excluded. He wanted to be mad, jealous even but he couldn’t. He was so incredibly turned on. He became so aroused watching the two. But it wasn’t fair. He needed some relief too.
“STOP!”
Penny and Sheldon stopped kissing and looked expectantly at Leonard.
“What?” Penny said through gritted teeth.
“I’ve come to realize that I no longer fit in this…equation.”
“Sweetie, I’m s…”
“No, no apologies…I know they will only be in vain. Anyway I’ve come up with a solution that will fix this little problem.” Leonard waited half a breath for any response.
“I call the shots.”
“Excuse me?” Penny questioned.
“As a compromise to letting you two have sex, I get to call the shots. I tell you what to do and how to do it, to my liking.”
Leonard walked over to his dresser and retrieved two items that he kept hidden from the couple on the bed.
“Sheldon you claim that you know anatomy.”
“It’s a fact not a claim.” Sheldon corrected.
“OK…it’s a fact that you know anatomy, my question is, do you know how to control said anatomy?”
“Well…umm…how do you mean?”
“Would you be able to control your own body when it’s simulated? Would you be able to hold it together when you are receiving the most amazing pleasure in your life? Are you really a Homo novus or just a regular homo sapien like the rest of us?”
“I…I…well…”
“I have the perfect experiment to find out.”
Leonard lifted his hands and let the contents slowly reveal themselves. Penny’s eyes lit up instantly. Leonard walked over to Penny and gave her the two silky materials. Penny squealed feeling the smoothness of the red scarves.
“Penny, tie Sheldon up to the bed.”
“Tie? What? No one is tying me up to anything.” Sheldon sat up, Penny still in his lap.
“Really? As a scientist I thought you liked experiments? Are you afraid of what the results might be? Are you afraid of being proven wrong?” Leonard challenged.
Sheldon glared at Leonard but scooted to rest his back against the headboard of the bed.
“Oh it’s junior rodeo on baby!” Penny exclaimed.
Leonard stood with his arms across his chest watching Penny safely and securely tie Sheldon’s wrists to the bed.
Sheldon tested his bindings. Penny’s skills of hog-tying were efficient. The tie wasn’t too tight to cut off circulation but tight enough that he wouldn’t be able to free himself. Sheldon watched as Penny admired her work, raw hunger evident in her eyes. His gaze then wandered to Leonard, who held his chin, contemplating their next move. Sheldon’s cock twitched at the prospects.
Penny sat on her heels, hands now resting on Sheldon’s thighs, lightly scraping her nails along them.
“What do you want me to do next Leonard?”
As Penny waited for orders, she had to admit to herself that she never anticipated the night’s events to turn out the way they have thus far. Truth be told she didn’t want a threesome, she just wanted Sheldon. She craved Sheldon. And now she has him where she wants him but with guidance from Leonard. Leonard, Penny laughed. She had no idea Leonard had it in him to be so…assertive, to be so commanding. That in itself turned her on.
“Stroke him. Just jerk Sheldon off.”
Sheldon gulped at Leonard’s request and stared wide-eyed as Penny inched her hand closer and closer to his hard erection. Sheldon sucked in a lung full of air when he felt the barest of touches as Penny’s fingers lightly enclosed him. Sheldon released a faint moan at the first stroke. Once a steady rhythm was established Sheldon rocked himself with Penny’s motion.
“Go faster.” Leonard ordered.
Penny sped up, locking eyes with Sheldon. Sheldon felt the pleasure building up in the pit of his stomach. His abdominal muscles tighten and his toes curled. Sheldon tilted his head back with eyes closed, willing his body to stay in control and not to succumb to the pleasure it desired.
“Faster.”
Sheldon held his bottom lip between his teeth. He averted his eyes from Penny’s. The look of raw lust in her eyes was just too much to handle. His eyes couldn’t focus on one thing; they kept wandering back to Penny and what she was doing to him. Then Sheldon made the mistake of landing his eyes on Penny’s naked breasts. They bounced deliciously along with her fast motions on his cock. His body started shaking. He could taste his pleasure begging to come out.
“Stop.”
Penny stopped immediately and released Sheldon from her grasp. Sheldon dropped his head forward, trying to regain control on his breathing. The task was beyond possible; every ounce of energy he has was rushing towards his cock. Release was the only thing that was on his mind.
“Now…” Leonard rubbed his hands together. “I think its high time Sheldon gets his first blowjob. What do you think Sheldon?”
Sheldon’s head snapped up. He wasn’t sure if he could endure the feel of Penny’s beautiful lips wrapped snuggly around him. Sheldon closed his eyes, he couldn’t watch no matter how desperately he wanted to. He has a point to prove and his resolve was rapidly coming undone and watching would most definitely set it off.
Penny placed a soft kiss to Sheldon’s tip. She licked her lips in preparation and tasted him on them. That little taste made her want more. Sticking her tongue out Penny licked Sheldon from base to tip. Once at the tip Penny sucked him into her mouth.
“Oh good lord…” Sheldon panted.
Penny slowly took Sheldon in inch by inch. Sheldon clenched and unclenched his fists. Absentmindedly he banged his head against the headboard. He was uncertain if the ringing in his ears came from that or from what Penny was doing. His senses were on overdrive, they all blended into one and he couldn’t pinpoint what sensation came from what or where.
“Penny I think Sheldon’s had enough teasing.”
Sheldon’s silent prayers were answered. He was on the edge of slipping into the abyss; he didn’t know how much longer he could last.
“Why don’t you show Sheldon what you can really do. Stop holding back.”
Sheldon looked down at Penny. Eyes intensely locked on one another, Penny took Sheldon’s full length in her mouth.
“SWEET JESUS!!” Sheldon cried out when he felt the head of his cock grasped by Penny’s throat.
Penny hollowed her cheeks and that’s when Sheldon started to thrash. Penny lifted her head until just the tip of Sheldon was between her lips. She licked the pre-cum that glistened out, causing more loud moans from Sheldon. Leonard urged Penny to quicken her pace and she obliged willingly.
“Oh god…Penny…Penny…ahhh…Penny.”
Sheldon’s head moved side to side, his hips up and down. Penny’s mouth felt so good. It was too much and yet not enough. The logic wasn’t sound but he couldn’t help it. It was the only way he could describe it.
Penny relished in Sheldon’s groans. They were so un-Sheldon like, so foreign to her ears that she did anything to make sure he kept on making those sounds. With her left hand Penny brought it to Sheldon’s neglected balls and gave them a firm squeeze.
“SHIT!”
Penny almost came right on the spot from hearing Sheldon curse. Never has she ever heard Sheldon curse, it was so…hot! Now there’s no way she would ever be able to hear Sheldon curse without getting aroused. With her free hand, Penny slid it down her stomach to rub her throbbing clit. She desperately needed relief. Hearing Sheldon cuss and moan, and with him practically fucking her mouth, she needed some proper attention.
Sheldon watched as Penny started fingering herself. The sight of Penny pleasuring herself plus the continuing bobbing of her head was over simulating Sheldon’s crazed senses. His orgasm was right there, he could feel it, he could taste it and he was going to let himself go. The delicious torture had to stop. He needed to admit defeat. All he needed was a little more…
“STOP!” Leonard commanded.
“FUCK!!” Sheldon yelled as Penny’s lips slipped away from his body. “GOD DAMN IT LEONARD!”
Penny and Leonard started at Sheldon in disbelief, never have they witnessed Sheldon burst out like that.
“If, if…I could blow your head up with…my, my mind…you would be lying lifelessly on the floor Leonard Hofstadter!”
Leonard burst in hysterics; the sound was pure evil to Sheldon.
“Getting a little frustrated are we?” Leonard teased; Sheldon just huffed. “Why didn’t you just let go?”
Sheldon looked down he wasn’t going to admit to Leonard that he almost let go, that he wanted to let go.
“Well you can thank Penny for the abrupt stop.” Leonard stated when Sheldon stayed silent.
Penny looked at Leonard in confusion. Leonard stepped towards the bed and grabbed Penny’s right hand.
“I don’t believe I said you could pleasure yourself.”
Penny’s mouth gaped open; she looked between the two men.
“I…god I couldn’t help myself. I’m sorry…just tell us what to do next.”
Leonard was proud of himself. He’s not quite sure how he did it, but he managed to hold a great power over the two. It was a nice boost of confidence. Leonard could feel the weight of their stare, they begged for the next move. Penny’s hand was still in his grasp, eyeing Sheldon; Leonard brought her fingers to his lips and gave them a little lick. The two gasped.
“You taste good Penny. So sweet. Doesn’t she taste good Sheldon?” Leonard looked at Sheldon as he continued to lap at Penny’s fingers. “I bet you’d like another taste. Isn’t Penny’s arousal delicious.”
The words were obscene to Sheldon but they spoke the truth. If he concentrated hard enough, he could still taste her on his tongue. His raging hormones were driving him crazy; he’d give anything to taste Penny again.
Leonard tugged Penny’s hand and pressed her fingers against Sheldon’s lips. The instant her fingers were there, Sheldon greedily took them into his mouth, sucking them clean. Penny moaned, squeezing her thighs together, the pressure between her legs was getting unbearable.
“Leonard…please…” Penny begged. “I need…god…please…”
“What do you want Penny?” He knew what she wanted but Leonard wanted to hear Penny say it.
“I want…” Penny looked into Sheldon’s now dark blue eyes. “Sheldon. I want Sheldon.”
“But what exactly is it that you want Penny? Say it.”
“I want to have sex with Sheldon. God I need to fuck him so bad…it hurts.”
Leonard sat at the very edge of the bed and nodded at Penny. Penny jumped into Sheldon’s lap, kissed him hungrily then quickly sank down on his throbbing cock.
“OH GOD!” They both screamed in unison.
Penny sat there, adjusting to Sheldon’s size; he was a magnificent fit. He stretched her wonderfully.
“Penny…” Sheldon whimpered. “Release my hands…I need to touch you.”
Penny went to reach for one of Sheldon’s tied hands.
“Oh I don’t think so.” Leonard piped in.
“Damn you Leonard Hofstadter!”
Sheldon gave Leonard an evil glare and in return Leonard gave Sheldon a wicked grin.
“Holy…mmm…Penny…” Sheldon moaned when he felt Penny’s walls tighten around him.
“Focus Dr. Cooper.” Penny teased as she began to rock her hips.
Sheldon quickly found Penny’s rhythm. Being inside Penny, feeling her wet heat, there simply weren’t any appropriate words to describe it. He would gladly stay lost in her forever.
Penny gripped one of Sheldon’s shoulders and the other held tightly onto the comforter beside her left thigh as she bounced up and down on Sheldon’s pulsating length. Penny tilted her head back and arched her back, creating a new angle to allow Sheldon to go deeper.
“CHRIST!”
Sheldon pulled at his restraints, the new angle was total bliss but it left Sheldon in agony. He needed to touch Penny everywhere. He longed to take her breasts into his hands and into his mouth. He wanted to kiss, lick, suck and bite her nipples that were begging for attention.
The pressure was building again. It was there. Sweet release was coming. Penny and Sheldon frantically rocked against each other.
“Stop.” This time Leonard didn’t hold back his laughter.
“That’s three strikes Leonard.”
“I swear I’m going to kill you.”
Leonard’s laughter roared even louder at their empty threats.
“Penny get off.”
“For Christ’s sake that’s what I’ve been trying to do.”
“No seriously get off of Sheldon.”
“You’re a man that truly has a death wish.”
Painfully Penny removed herself from Sheldon. Leonard got off the bed and walked over to one of Sheldon’s tied wrists. Gently Leonard freed Sheldon. Sheldon massaged each wrist and examined the red marks that didn’t fade away instantly. Penny took a wrist in her hand and placed a kiss on Sheldon’s pulse point that raced wildly. Leonard went back to sitting at the end of the bed.
“Penny face me, on your hands and knees.” Leonard instructed.
If Penny’s pupils could dilate any more, if her body could flush any more, if her pussy could become any wetter, they all would have done so at Leonard’s instructions. She knew what he was asking for and god she couldn’t wait.
Penny threw her hair to one side and looked over her shoulder to Sheldon, who just sat there contemplating what was going on.
“Fuck me Sheldon. Hard.”
Sheldon was taken back by Penny’s vulgar language. He looked at Leonard but only received a shrug. Getting up on his knees, Sheldon held his cock in one hand and ran it along Penny’s wet slit. Penny thrust her hips back, wanting Sheldon inside her once again. Sheldon placed himself at Penny’s entrance and slammed into her.
All three moaned. Penny watched as Leonard finally removed his boxers. Leonard was just as aroused as she and Sheldon were.
Sheldon began to thrust relentlessly. He’s never been so aroused in his entire life nor for this long period of time for that matter. His grip on Penny’s hips was tight, bound to leave a mark.
“Sheldon…” Penny breathlessly moaned. “Harder…mmm…deeper.”
“Sheldon…hair…Penny’s hair.” Leonard stroked himself, watching the two.
Sheldon didn’t know what order to take. He didn’t know what Leonard meant by Penny’s hair but he couldn’t formulate the question out loud. His brain was mush and it only had one thing on its mind.
Sheldon looked down where his and Penny’s bodies were joined together. The image of him thrusting in and out of Penny will forever be imprinted in his mind. His eyes slowly wandered up to Penny’s “soup” tattoo and with one finger Sheldon traced it. The action received a giggle/moan from Penny. Sheldon then flatten his palm against Penny’s lower back. That hand inched its way up to Penny’s neck. From there Sheldon ran his fingers through Penny’s hair. Penny groaned loudly when Sheldon suddenly fisted her hair and gently tugged on it. With another slight pull Penny had her back pressed against Sheldon’s chest.
Penny turned her head and sought out Sheldon’s lips. Another pull and Sheldon angled Penny’s head to properly kiss her deeply.
“God Sheldon…I’m almost there.”
“Me too…” Sheldon licked Penny’s neck then bit down.
“OHHHH!”
Penny forced her hips harder into Sheldon’s. Her left hand went behind and grabbed Sheldon’s ass.
“Touch her Sheldon.” Leonard started pumping faster.
The hand that once resided in Penny’s hair went and grabbed firmly onto her boob. His fingers pinched and pulled at its nipple.
“Mmmm…”
With his hips slamming madly into Penny’s, Sheldon reached over and pressed his thumb strongly on Penny’s clit.
“AHHH…”
“Not yet Penny.” Leonard requested.
“I can’t…don’t stop…please Sheldon …God Leonard…”
With her free hand, Penny held onto Sheldon’s hand that pressed hard onto her clit. Her and Sheldon’s movements were perfectly in sync. Penny couldn’t stand it any longer.
“SHELDON! FUCK!”
Penny’s climax hit her hard. The ripples of pleasure were endless. Penny slumped forward, her body exhausted but Sheldon still continued to pump into her.
“Sheldon…let go.”
Despite Penny’s spasming walls creating a vice like grip, Sheldon was determined to last a little longer. Quickly pulling out, Sheldon flipped Penny onto her back. Before he re-entered her, Sheldon threw Penny’s left leg over his shoulder. One hand held onto Penny’s thigh for dear life and the other held the comforter beside Penny’s head.
Sheldon pressed his forehead against Penny’s; their short breaths of air mingling together. Penny didn’t think it was possible but another powerful orgasm struck her, with Sheldon’s name on her lips.
“PENNY!!” Penny’s pleasure laced screams was Sheldon’s and Leonard’s undoing.
Exhausted and totally spent, Sheldon collapsed on top of Penny.
The room was quiet, the only thing that could be heard was their breathing. Sheldon rolled to Penny’s side and quickly Penny pressed her back against his chest needing to still be close to him. She looked over to Leonard and beckoned him to her. He laid chest to chest with her. Nobody said a word for a few minutes. Penny’s giggling then broke the silence.
“How are we going to top the next ‘Anything can happen Thursday’?”
“We have to wait that long?” Sheldon questioned in disbelief.
“Well I guess you’re a regular Homo sapien after all Sheldon. Who knew?” Penny’s laughter roared the room.