OK, so.

[st_anon]

I gave up on replying in the other threads last post; there was some quite long discussion going on, and I was a little unsure of who should be replied to

Comments

[anonymous]

I was fine with the comm as it was, and I think that the racist comments would have been best ignored rather than given a lot of attention...

Anyway, I'm concerned that now it'll be that anyone who doesn't like NewUhura is automatically called a racist.

[anonymous]

anyone who doesn't like NewUhura is automatically called a racist

I noticed that...

Personally - I kinda didn't like Nu!Uhura...I do like Zoe Saldana, but I didn't like how Uhura was written (I also wanted more scotty, but hey...can't have everything) I prefered tos Uhura...

I also didn't like the fact that the women's dresses had no rank...

[cleojones]

You shouldn't be.
st_anon was really clear.

There's a difference between OH MY GAWD UHURA IS SUCH A BITCH...please write this prompt where her skin gets ripped off, because she sucks and is awful.

... often w/ subsequent discussion of why Uhura's skin should be ripped off

and...

I want Uhura's skin to be ripped off.

I haven't seen *ANY* race/sex wank in the second situation.

Only the first.

[anonymous]

Because you haven't seen it totally means it doesn't exist, right?

Oh, wait. Maybe you're confusing wanks you have seen and wanks you have CAUSED. Because god knows the only contribution you've ever made towards this meme is wank.

[anonymous]

Oh hey, while you find all those links that don't exist, can you find the ones where McCoy or Kirk or Spock are equally raked over the coals for their objectively douche behavior?

Because really, some of you keep trotting that old "well Kirk/McCoy/Spock get bashed too!" chestnut, and no one has yet put out. Maybe you can enlighten us all.

[anonymous]

wait, who's yelling at who now

i'm so confused.

[anonymous]

I have seen a long detailed prompt in which the person prompted for group!Kirk!rape and specifically said that they don't like Kirk and think he should also think he deserves this treatment. You know what happened with this prompt? Nothing. Nothing at all. NO wank, no calling names, no accusation of sexism and racism (against a while male).

[anonymous]

Link. And then I'll believe you. Of course, that doesn't change the fact that ratio is significantly skewed in Uhura's direction. See also the difference between bashing a character in a prompt, or using a character's personality to get them laid -- which, in a kink meme, can also include non-con as rape-fantasies aren't too uncommon. So even if you do link, I doubt that the rape is punishment, per se, but an excuse to get Kirk bound, gagged and probably weeping from every orifice.

But I'm sure they all support you in PM, lazy-anon-who's-too-lazy-to-fucking-link.

[anonymous]

No, it was I remember very well, a long prompt, in which the poster specifically said that Kirk is a slut and they hate him, Kirk gets gangraped on some sort of a SF academy party because he's such a slut, he deserves it and furthermore Kirk, believes he deserves it. No happy ending for Kirk.
Ratio is unfavorable, that's true but denying prompts like that exist at all, like some people do? Illogical.

I am not lazy, I just don't feel like spending HOURS to dig through old unfilled prompts to find it. I didn't report it because I respected Anon's need to read some sick shit that made them happy. Back then O left all that stuff alone and forgot about it. It's only NOW AS YOU CAN SEE, mod had posted a specific guidelines what to do. If i read it now? I would report the shit out of it.

[anonymous]

I have seen it. Many times. Made me left the meme for 2 months and now I'm back and I see things actually went worse...