Fic: "Standing" for twisting_path

Apr 06, 2007 23:57

Err.. did anyone see the subject line hehehe? *iz 10*

Title: Standing
Author: remarked
Recipient: twisting_path
Rating: PG-13
Character: Minerva McGonagall
Warnings: ( Read more... )

springen 2007

Leave a comment

Comments 45

fourth_rose April 6 2007, 19:08:44 UTC
That was a great take on McGonagall's character, and a very interesting story! I must admit that Dumbledore's reaction to Ron and Hermione's death seems terribly blasé to me, but I can't help thinking that this is quite IC for him, given the way he keeps endangering students in the books when it suits his purposes...

Reply

noticeably May 16 2007, 00:48:36 UTC
Thank you so much! I'm glad you liked it! And, yeah. I had some trouble writing Dumbledore in this, but I sort of had that same thought, about him always putting the students in danger.

Reply


snegurochka_lee April 6 2007, 19:24:31 UTC
Nice! I liked Minerva's voice here. :)

Reply

noticeably May 16 2007, 00:49:11 UTC
Thank you! I'm glad you liked it! :))

Reply


sapphiretragedy April 6 2007, 19:43:13 UTC
Brilliant!

I love this insight into Minerva. It was a wonderful character sketch.

Reply

noticeably May 16 2007, 00:49:53 UTC
Thanks so much! I'm glad you enjoyed it. :D

Reply


bethbethbeth April 6 2007, 19:47:54 UTC
Oh, this is well done! Nicely written and emotionally powerful. What was particularly interesting to me was how well you caught the quality of youthful insecurity in the face of new responsibilities that never seems to leave anybody, regardless of how old they get.

Reply

noticeably May 16 2007, 00:52:00 UTC
Thank you so much! I'm really glad that you enjoyed this. I had so much trouble writing parts of this, and wasn't sure if I had gotten the themes across in the end or not, so it's nice to know that I managed. :)

Reply


mk_tortie April 6 2007, 19:58:41 UTC
Oh, this gave me goose bumps at the end! Absolutely fantastic :)

Reply

noticeably May 16 2007, 00:52:31 UTC
I'm glad you liked it! :)

Reply


Leave a comment

Up