My thoughts...
Here are my thoughts of the first group of 8 in order of favorite to not favorite.
katie webber sffdjklkj! I. LOVE. HER. Personally I loved her song choice. She proved that she isn't just some pretty blonde popstar wannabe, and she is here to show that she can do more than be what she is made out to. [if that made sense]. She has amazing presence and vocal ability, and I would love to see her in the top 12!
diana degarmo she is soooo cute! I think she is amazing for her age. She is better then people older than her. She is just.. great. The end. She knows what song to chose, she knows how to use it, thats it, she wins.
erskine walcott smooth. i really liked him better than others, but he reminds me of charles. you don't want people to think of someone else when you sing, i would rather just be known as me. I see him as a wildcard, but i can see him getting through too.
marque lynche he is the cutest. i didn't really like his song choice, I think he could have chosen something better. I felt like he was holding his voice back durning the first part then really hit the power notes. He didn't seem to know how to control is voice to keep it soft then bring it out, he just held back. I don't know. But I love his voice and the second part was awesome. But he won't get through
ashley thomas simon is right about her. no spark. she has this amazing voice, and really really good control. She is really cute too. I remember saying to my brother at the start of her performance,"wow good control", but i remember nothing after that.
matt metzger he reminds me of tyler hamilton [canadian idol finalist], but he sorta sings like millsy. of course millsy is better, and i hated tyler come the finals so i don't know, come up with something from that.
jennifer hudson something about her really really bothers me, i don't know what though. I see her as a wildcard. She reminds me of Kelli Glover [ai1 semi-finalist/wildcard] but it could be just the hair lmfao. No, they both had really good voices, but just never made it through. I don't know thats not a good critique.
fantasia barrino the judges are on crack. she is ok, just not my personal taste at all. no thanks, send her home bring back draeh!
As of now I definately see Nicole Tieri [Scooter Girl] as a wildcard. I mean, she has so much press already. On ET they did a story on her the night after the show of her first audition. They went to her hometown and talked to one of her friends about her disorder. Yesterday she was on Extra talking about it. I really feel like the judges planned it out. To cut her and bring her back as a wildcard and put her through to the next round. It's a ratings/publicity thing.
Ok well thats my commentary.
Now everyone go join idol_directory to pimp your idol related communities.
katie webber sffdjklkj! I. LOVE. HER. Personally I loved her song choice. She proved that she isn't just some pretty blonde popstar wannabe, and she is here to show that she can do more than be what she is made out to. [if that made sense]. She has amazing presence and vocal ability, and I would love to see her in the top 12!
diana degarmo she is soooo cute! I think she is amazing for her age. She is better then people older than her. She is just.. great. The end. She knows what song to chose, she knows how to use it, thats it, she wins.
erskine walcott smooth. i really liked him better than others, but he reminds me of charles. you don't want people to think of someone else when you sing, i would rather just be known as me. I see him as a wildcard, but i can see him getting through too.
marque lynche he is the cutest. i didn't really like his song choice, I think he could have chosen something better. I felt like he was holding his voice back durning the first part then really hit the power notes. He didn't seem to know how to control is voice to keep it soft then bring it out, he just held back. I don't know. But I love his voice and the second part was awesome. But he won't get through
ashley thomas simon is right about her. no spark. she has this amazing voice, and really really good control. She is really cute too. I remember saying to my brother at the start of her performance,"wow good control", but i remember nothing after that.
matt metzger he reminds me of tyler hamilton [canadian idol finalist], but he sorta sings like millsy. of course millsy is better, and i hated tyler come the finals so i don't know, come up with something from that.
jennifer hudson something about her really really bothers me, i don't know what though. I see her as a wildcard. She reminds me of Kelli Glover [ai1 semi-finalist/wildcard] but it could be just the hair lmfao. No, they both had really good voices, but just never made it through. I don't know thats not a good critique.
fantasia barrino the judges are on crack. she is ok, just not my personal taste at all. no thanks, send her home bring back draeh!
As of now I definately see Nicole Tieri [Scooter Girl] as a wildcard. I mean, she has so much press already. On ET they did a story on her the night after the show of her first audition. They went to her hometown and talked to one of her friends about her disorder. Yesterday she was on Extra talking about it. I really feel like the judges planned it out. To cut her and bring her back as a wildcard and put her through to the next round. It's a ratings/publicity thing.
Ok well thats my commentary.
Now everyone go join idol_directory to pimp your idol related communities.