Found! Kidnapped Jared, Dark Jensen
I read this story forever ago and it just popped back into my brain. Jensen is rich and owns an island or something and Jared’s boyfriend sells him to Jensen. It’s pretty much non-con sex for I think five or so chapters. At one point they’re on a boat and someone else teases Jared and drugs him. Jensen calls Jared “toy” a lot. Does this sound familiar to anyone?
UPDATE: It's called "Acquisitions" by Tipsy_Kitty
UPDATE: It's called "Acquisitions" by Tipsy_Kitty