Demonic and Angelic Sam and Dean threatened at hunter bar by hunters with the Colt
Being more familiar with fanfic than the show itself I can't remember which brother said yes to Lucifer and which said yes to Michael, but this story takes place after that, told from the POV of an elderly man they saved (with his mom and sister) when he was a child. He's hanging out at a hunters' bar when Sam and Dean come in. One of the brothers is "blind," eye's closed behind sunglasses to restrain his "Glory." They're threated by a bunch of younger hunters, one of whom has The Colt. They shoot one brother dead and the last thing the elderly man sees before shutting his eyes and urging the young waitresses with him to do the same, is the hunters being pinned to the walls and dragged upwards before the other brother's Glory shines out his eyes, burning them up as they scream.
I've been trying to find this one again for over a week (plus the three day I've been attempting to post this). Anybody know which story this is? I promise I'll label it better this time so I won't lose it. Thanks.