in response to Isaac's claim that cities that allow handguns are "safer"

Sep 30, 2004 20:13

check out this article on gun violence if you want numbers.

isaac004"I don't have the data on hand, but the trend's in other cities, states, and country's show that when gun or drug laws are increased, the crime goes up. When gun or drug laws are reduced, crime in most cases drops."

anyway, logic and data says if you increase the amout of guns in a place, the number of gun related deaths is going to increase. Now I get the whole constitutional right to bear arms. My main problem with the house's vote to legalize handguns in D.C. is the fact that they are claiming the city will be safer. It clearly will not be. In the article they said that gun related deaths, while high relative to the nation, have been on the decline since banning handguns. If you want to legalize handguns, I don't want to hear the bullshit about it saving lives...

from the NewScientist (link above): "Douglas Wiebe of the Firearm Injury Center at Penn (FICAP) at the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia agrees. Last month, Wiebe and colleagues found that people who keep guns at home have a 72 per cent greater chance of being killed by firearms compared with those who do not, and are 3.44 times as likely to commit suicide (Annals of Emergency Medicine, vol 41, p 771). A 1997 survey by the CDC that compared the US with 25 other industrialised countries, including the UK and Australia, showed that the number of gun-related homicides in the US per 100,00 children below the age of 15 was 16 times that of all the other countries combined. The proportion of children below 15 who use guns to kill themselves was 11 times higher.

Making handguns safer
Many people in the US legitimately own firearms, and with no realistic prospect of gun ownership being banned that is unlikely to change. Around half a million guns are stolen from people's homes every year, many of which go on to be used in a crime. Making these weapons childproof, or designing them so that they can only be used by an authorised owner, could help reduce the number of gun-related injuries and deaths, says Teret."

so there are some numbers for you. Criminals get guns by stealing ones that are legally purchased. Sure, they get them other ways too, but legalizing them in D.C. is just giving them another source. Second, people who own handguns are 72% more likely to be killed by a firearm! There are some numbers for you.

I never want to own a gun. I don't like guns. I don't have a problem with people hunting or owning guns though, since it's written into the constitution. But this doesn't mean gunownership and manufacturing shouldn't be regulated! I mean, come on people! Furthermore, don't bullshit me and say it is safer if people legally own guns. It isn't! Look at the UK. They don't allow guns, and people don't get shot.

...any comments... bring it on.
Previous post Next post
Up