A guy who actually took me into consideration, rather than going through typical, obligatory romantic motions...
He didn't get red roses, but pink tulips. He not only washed my car, but also put new flowers in the little vase. He didn't buy me a box of chocolates. He baked me a batch of cookies from scratch. He didn't just take me out to eat. He took me out to sushi on the nicer side of town. He even picked out a Rose wine because of my last name.