Round 02 - Challenge 04 - Results
Eliminated:
- phistolemon_ [06 votes]
Please stick around for the special challenge and for voting! ♥
---
People's choice:
- lunglock [04 votes]
---
Mod's Choice:
- semi_subtle
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Votes:
[N = Negative votes & P = Positive votes]
01] - banana53080 - N = 3/P = 0
[x] "The icon seems to have an unoriginal crop"
[x] "the coloring is somewhat bland and because of this, the icon itself is slightly lacking - it could use a border or text of some kind to make it a bit less plain (for lack of a better word)"
[x] "the coloring (and possible texture use) overpowers snape"
02] - phistolemon_ - N = 6/P = 2
[x] "the contrast is set to high and the lines on his face are harsh - the font does not "fit" the image (too bubbly for snape)"
[x] "text doesn't fit well with the rest of the icon"
[x] "Not enough contrast"
[x] "Font and colour of the text don't fit with the icon general idea."
[x] "the text is somewhat awkwardly placed and the color does not fit with the coloring of the overall icon. The image is fuzzy and muted in it’s coloring and the cropping does not balance the icon nor draw the eye to a single focal point."
[x] "The colour and placement of the text does not compliment the icon."
[x] "good crop, interesting text placement and font choice but it works"
[x] "I just like the icon the most, especially the font, although there were a couple more I liked, this stood out more."
03] - spikesbint - N = 2/P = 1
[x] "crop is somewhat boring be so centered. font does not work well, the s is getting lost in the blackness."
[x] "The text colour is distracting from the picture portion."
[x] Positive [No comment]
04] - semi_subtle - N = 1/P = 1
[x] "there's not enough depth in this one. the picture looks grainy."
[x] Positive [No comment]
05] - so_Severus - N = 4/P = 1
[x] "the cropping is a bit awkward (the tip of his nose is cut off!)"
[x] "poorly cropped, would be better with more subtleties in the midtones."
[x] "The cropping of Snape is odd. Too far left."
[x] "Cropping -- looks like the very tip of his nose is cut off?"
[x] "Great cropping, textures and tiny text work perfectly fine with the image."
06] - lunglock - N = 2/P = 4
[x] "Snape is almost indisitinguisable."
[x] "weird crop. The icon is lacking a strong focal point and is bottom heavy."
[x] "gorgeous simple, b/w icon. I love how even small Snape stands out so much"
[x] "The black and white is perfectly contrasted and has great depth, and the cropping really draws the eye to the action of the scene."
[x] "well balanced b/w icon and great crop. I like that snape's in the corner and not, let's say right in the middle :)"
[x] Positive [No comment]
07] - whorl - N = 4/P = 1
[x] "Snape's face is a bit blurry and the brightness of the "flames" takes away from the subject"
[x] "The saturation is too overpowering and the subject gets lost."
[x] "snape's face is a bit blurry"
[x] "Image needs a little bit of sharpen and the black border doesn't work fine with it."
[x] "I really love the cropping on this icon, and I think the effect of the spell cast from his wand makes the icon feel dynamic."
08] - shadowsong_13 - N = 2/P = 2
[x] "the black and white is too heavily contrasted. The clip transition is not particularly smooth. The tiny text is awkwardly placed and not well balanced with the main text. The text is a bit sharp, and the white streak in the center of the icon is there without an apparent aesthetic reason."
[x] "the animation is nice, though the ripped paper effect doesn't really work here."
[x] "the BW is well done and the animation is fantastic - great framing and texture use"
[x] "Although the image is small, it is clear. (I really like it.)"
Participants Status
The following people are still in the contest. If you're name is not in this list, it means you have been eliminated/disqualified.
banana53080
irdamajere
lunglock
semi_subtle
shadowsong_13
so_severus
spikesbint
whorl
Thank you to all who participated in the challenge and voting ^_^
The next challenge shall be posted soon!
- phistolemon_ [06 votes]
Please stick around for the special challenge and for voting! ♥
---
People's choice:
- lunglock [04 votes]
---
Mod's Choice:
- semi_subtle
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Votes:
[N = Negative votes & P = Positive votes]
01] - banana53080 - N = 3/P = 0
[x] "The icon seems to have an unoriginal crop"
[x] "the coloring is somewhat bland and because of this, the icon itself is slightly lacking - it could use a border or text of some kind to make it a bit less plain (for lack of a better word)"
[x] "the coloring (and possible texture use) overpowers snape"
02] - phistolemon_ - N = 6/P = 2
[x] "the contrast is set to high and the lines on his face are harsh - the font does not "fit" the image (too bubbly for snape)"
[x] "text doesn't fit well with the rest of the icon"
[x] "Not enough contrast"
[x] "Font and colour of the text don't fit with the icon general idea."
[x] "the text is somewhat awkwardly placed and the color does not fit with the coloring of the overall icon. The image is fuzzy and muted in it’s coloring and the cropping does not balance the icon nor draw the eye to a single focal point."
[x] "The colour and placement of the text does not compliment the icon."
[x] "good crop, interesting text placement and font choice but it works"
[x] "I just like the icon the most, especially the font, although there were a couple more I liked, this stood out more."
03] - spikesbint - N = 2/P = 1
[x] "crop is somewhat boring be so centered. font does not work well, the s is getting lost in the blackness."
[x] "The text colour is distracting from the picture portion."
[x] Positive [No comment]
04] - semi_subtle - N = 1/P = 1
[x] "there's not enough depth in this one. the picture looks grainy."
[x] Positive [No comment]
05] - so_Severus - N = 4/P = 1
[x] "the cropping is a bit awkward (the tip of his nose is cut off!)"
[x] "poorly cropped, would be better with more subtleties in the midtones."
[x] "The cropping of Snape is odd. Too far left."
[x] "Cropping -- looks like the very tip of his nose is cut off?"
[x] "Great cropping, textures and tiny text work perfectly fine with the image."
06] - lunglock - N = 2/P = 4
[x] "Snape is almost indisitinguisable."
[x] "weird crop. The icon is lacking a strong focal point and is bottom heavy."
[x] "gorgeous simple, b/w icon. I love how even small Snape stands out so much"
[x] "The black and white is perfectly contrasted and has great depth, and the cropping really draws the eye to the action of the scene."
[x] "well balanced b/w icon and great crop. I like that snape's in the corner and not, let's say right in the middle :)"
[x] Positive [No comment]
07] - whorl - N = 4/P = 1
[x] "Snape's face is a bit blurry and the brightness of the "flames" takes away from the subject"
[x] "The saturation is too overpowering and the subject gets lost."
[x] "snape's face is a bit blurry"
[x] "Image needs a little bit of sharpen and the black border doesn't work fine with it."
[x] "I really love the cropping on this icon, and I think the effect of the spell cast from his wand makes the icon feel dynamic."
08] - shadowsong_13 - N = 2/P = 2
[x] "the black and white is too heavily contrasted. The clip transition is not particularly smooth. The tiny text is awkwardly placed and not well balanced with the main text. The text is a bit sharp, and the white streak in the center of the icon is there without an apparent aesthetic reason."
[x] "the animation is nice, though the ripped paper effect doesn't really work here."
[x] "the BW is well done and the animation is fantastic - great framing and texture use"
[x] "Although the image is small, it is clear. (I really like it.)"
Participants Status
The following people are still in the contest. If you're name is not in this list, it means you have been eliminated/disqualified.
banana53080
irdamajere
lunglock
semi_subtle
shadowsong_13
so_severus
spikesbint
whorl
Thank you to all who participated in the challenge and voting ^_^
The next challenge shall be posted soon!