Mod!Hat: Key & Ratings

May 02, 2008 13:58

I figured making this up would be helpful. It can always be found in the profile of this community.

Key & Ratings*
One Star = Almost There, Lacking in the Good, Little too much in the Bad
Two Stars = Average, Good
Three Stars = Above Average, Great
Four Stars = Impressive, Really Great
Five Stars = Outstanding, Awe

Angst - Marked on quality, appropriateness, believability, etc. If it's a very angsty story is will likely have more Angst-Stars, but only if it's done well.

Charact's - Characterization; How well the characters remain true. This includes aspects of dialogue and actions.

Details/Style - The author's writing style, descriptions, flow, grammar, etc.

Humor - Marked on quality, appropriateness, believability, etc. If it's a very humorous story is will likely have more Humor-Stars, but only if it's done well.

Originality - Kinda self explanatory, don't you think? The more original, the more stars.

Overall Judges the overall quality.

Romance - Romance has to do with love, how much love is factored into the story, without the essence of Sap. There's a fine distinction. A very romantic story will include tender things, maybe some roses, love-making, self-sacrafice for loved ones, etc.

Smut  -  the sex, passion. Marked on realness, writing, appropriateness, believability, etc. It is not marked on the amount, style (vanilla, bondage), or adult ratings.

UST - Unresolved Sexual Tension. Marked on quality, appropriateness, believability, etc. More UST in the story is will likely give it more UST-Stars, but only if it's done well.

Wibble/Sap - I'm not one for mush, but for those of you who are, the Stars rate the integrity of the Sap. A lot of sugary-sweet, mushy revelations or declarations of love will have a low Star rating. Meanwhile, appropriate, meaningful confessions will score higher.

*This will be updated as new categories come along.

mod, key & rating

Previous post Next post
Up