This was to be a response to a different discussion, but I fFound myself changing subjects a bit. So here's a slightly different kind of discussion fFor you, as well
( Read more... )
I really enjoyed Ender's Game, but I really felt any need to read any of the other books Card wrote. In some ways, I felt Ender's Game stood on its own and didn't need sequels.
If Card was willing to leave things well enough alone, I could stand behind Ender's Game as a good book by a man I don't agree with on many social and philosophical issues. But if he's going to change it so it echoes his current dogma, then it's not going to be the classic I once read.
As far as his stuff stealing from LeGuins, I honestly can't say. I think I tried to read her stuff a couple of times but was never able to really get into it.
Comments 1
If Card was willing to leave things well enough alone, I could stand behind Ender's Game as a good book by a man I don't agree with on many social and philosophical issues. But if he's going to change it so it echoes his current dogma, then it's not going to be the classic I once read.
As far as his stuff stealing from LeGuins, I honestly can't say. I think I tried to read her stuff a couple of times but was never able to really get into it.
Reply
Leave a comment