s3r3: voting results
ELIMINATED:
i've decided not to eliminate anyone this time: firstly, we have a tie. and secondly, there have been 2 people dropped out, so it's only fair, i think.
PEOPLE'S CHOICE:
kristallmond
with +5 votes
congrats! ;]
MOD'S CHOICE:
purelycomplex
I love the use of sky textures and the compostion in general.
TALLIES:
1 --- = -3
2 ++ = +2
3 = 0
4 +--- = -2
5 --- = -3
6 -- = -2
7 +-+++ = +3
8 +++++ = +5
COMMENTS:
1:
-#01 - The text doesn't really go with the icon, and I really dislike the cropping.
-#01 - the picture is too sharpened
-#1 - text use is strange, difficult to read
2:
+#02 - Just absolute gorgeous. Brilliant use of Textures and Coloring.
+#02 - great use of textures
4:
+4 - The icon is simple but looks very sharp and clean.
-#4 - very plain, slightly blurry
-4 - the icon is too ordinary: no interesting coloration and crop
-#4 - the colouring and cropping could have been done better.
5:
-5 - The texture seems to really obscure the rest of the icon.
-5 - the icon is too dark so that the text is difficult to read. It would be much better, if the icon was brighter.
-#5 - the font's a bit hard to read.
6:
-6 - The icon is too yellow and the texture doesn't seem to compliment the icon.
-#06 - Aaagh, the ever staying Red dot of doom! I really dislike the coloring.
7:
+#07 - The coloring is perfect, and the crop is just excellent. The texts works well.
-#07 - both coloring and use of text don't work with the picture
+#7 - nice colouring and text use
+7 - cool crop and nice use of text (both text and positioning)
+#7 - I really like the colouring and the crop of it.
8:
+8 - Good colouring, love the extra sky and the composition as a whole.
+#08 - amazing coloring
+#8 - wonderful colouring, very eye-catching
+8 - awesome coloring (color of the sky, Maxxie)
+#8 - Really nice colouring. :)
ps. i'll upload the banners asap, sorry )
i've decided not to eliminate anyone this time: firstly, we have a tie. and secondly, there have been 2 people dropped out, so it's only fair, i think.
PEOPLE'S CHOICE:
kristallmond
with +5 votes
congrats! ;]
MOD'S CHOICE:
purelycomplex
I love the use of sky textures and the compostion in general.
TALLIES:
1 --- = -3
2 ++ = +2
3 = 0
4 +--- = -2
5 --- = -3
6 -- = -2
7 +-+++ = +3
8 +++++ = +5
COMMENTS:
1:
-#01 - The text doesn't really go with the icon, and I really dislike the cropping.
-#01 - the picture is too sharpened
-#1 - text use is strange, difficult to read
2:
+#02 - Just absolute gorgeous. Brilliant use of Textures and Coloring.
+#02 - great use of textures
4:
+4 - The icon is simple but looks very sharp and clean.
-#4 - very plain, slightly blurry
-4 - the icon is too ordinary: no interesting coloration and crop
-#4 - the colouring and cropping could have been done better.
5:
-5 - The texture seems to really obscure the rest of the icon.
-5 - the icon is too dark so that the text is difficult to read. It would be much better, if the icon was brighter.
-#5 - the font's a bit hard to read.
6:
-6 - The icon is too yellow and the texture doesn't seem to compliment the icon.
-#06 - Aaagh, the ever staying Red dot of doom! I really dislike the coloring.
7:
+#07 - The coloring is perfect, and the crop is just excellent. The texts works well.
-#07 - both coloring and use of text don't work with the picture
+#7 - nice colouring and text use
+7 - cool crop and nice use of text (both text and positioning)
+#7 - I really like the colouring and the crop of it.
8:
+8 - Good colouring, love the extra sky and the composition as a whole.
+#08 - amazing coloring
+#8 - wonderful colouring, very eye-catching
+8 - awesome coloring (color of the sky, Maxxie)
+#8 - Really nice colouring. :)
ps. i'll upload the banners asap, sorry )