s3r2: voting results

Feb 09, 2009 20:20

huge thanks to all who voted <3
ELIMINATED:


xbenji65; with -6 votes


city_bird; with -6 votes
I am very sorry! Hope to see you both next session.

PEOPLE'S CHOICE:


purelycomplex; with +8 votes; banner
I am completely agree, the icon is gorgeous <3

MOD'S CHOICE:


sarenka_xd; banner
Love the composition and the colour, icon looks very nice and catchy :]

TALLIES:
1 ++ = +2
2 ++ = +2
3 -- = -2
4 ------ = -6 = eliminated
5 +++ = +3 = mc
6 ------ = -6 = eliminated
7 - = -1
8 ++++++++ = +8 = pc
9 -+ = 0

COMMENTS:

001;
+#01 - love the use of space and text
+01 - The icon is sharp and clean and the text is well executed.
002;
+#2 - love the colours, font, text, everything
+#2 - nice cropping and texture use
003;
-#3 - coloring is too blue, don't like the crop
-#03 - the images needs more sharpening and the coloring seems a bit off
004;
-#004 - the coloring doesn't fit with the background
-#4 - don't like the background texture, colours and icon is too blured.
-#4 - colouring is too pale
-04 - The background doesn't really compliment the cut out and just makes it look messy.
-#4 - bad colouring, texture use
-#004 - Too much contrast between background and Katie.
005;
+#005 - really nice coloring and use of texture
+#005 - THe background is really cool, so is the cropping.
+#5 - great texture use
006;
-#006 - the coloring, the texture and the font just don't look good
-#06 - it's a bit oversharpened and the light blob is distracting. very interesting crop though
-#006 - I like the cropping, but the colouring isn't very good. I don't like the font.
-06 - The colouring isn't very complimentary and the text just looks odd.
-#6 - oversharpened
-#006 - Colouring seems very unnatural.
007;
-#7 - strange cropping
008;
+#008 - nice effect, and lovely coloring
+#8 - very original icon, nice font, text and colours
+#08 - very creative composition
+#008 - The cropping and combination of the two pictures is really well done.
+#8 - interesting blending and cropping, nice text use
+08 - Great colouring and use of text.
+#8 - great colouring, nice text
+#008 - Unusual composition and lovely colouring.
009;
-#009 - The cropping could have been done better, and the colouring isn't great.
+#009 - Interesting composition, nice colouring and use of textures.

s3, r2, results

Previous post Next post
Up