s2r6: voting results

Sep 15, 2008 13:33


ELIMINATED


whatifmaybe
with -4 votes
Very sorry ;( hope to see you next time.

PEOPLE'S CHOICE


aberrantcliche
with +4 votes
Congrats, really great icon!

MOD'S CHOICE


kristallmond
I like the composition and the texture using, everything looks perfect!

TALLIES
1 + = +1
2 --- = -3
3 ++++ = +4 = pc
4 ---- = -4 = elimination
5 + = +1
6 no votes
7 + = +1 = mc

COMMENTS

1:
+001 - It's simple and pretty, I like the texture
2:
-#2 - you can barely make out the picture because of the texture, too dark
-#02 - It's really hard to make out what is on the icon.
-#2 - the cropping is mediocre and the colouring isn't that different from the original shot
3:
+#03 - Nice composition and great use of black and white.
+#03 - Great use of space and the contrast is eally good.
+03 - Love the use of black and white and contrasting here! Even though I think the icon could be brightened up a bit more, its' still wonderful!
+3- original texture and cropping for that picture
4:
-004 - I don't really like the blending(?) nor the blurry yellow texture on it
-#04 - The texture used takes too much place, we don't really see Chris & Jal.
-04 - The use of colours here is pretty, but the faces of Chris and Jal are too obscured and the texture just makes thing worse.
-4 - the texture don`t match the icon
5:
+#5 - love the colouring and the cropping. it sets the mood for the icon really well
7:
+#7 - great cut-out, awesome composition

s2, results, r6

Previous post Next post
Up