HMD: Constructive & Positive Feedback!

[thepull_mods]

New This Month! Please Read:
This Post is for BOTH Pro and Con crit!

This post is for providing Constructive AND Positive feedback for fellow players regarding how they play their characters in Siren's Pull.

Constructive criticism should be just that - please avoid bashing or being rude. If you have critique for a characterization, please support

Comments

[mentis_reae]

Player Name: Hope
Character Name: Miles Edgeworth
Character Journal: mentis_reae
Character Canon Source: Ace Attorney

Character Name: Dolph
Character Journal: not_lundgren
Character Canon Source: Suikoden V

[serratedwings]

TSUUUUUUUUUUUNWORTH no, but seriously -- I'm constantly impressed with your characterization and the amount of IC... involvement, for lack of a better term, that Edgeworth manages to keep up. And, well, given that he's Edgeworth, it makes complete sense that he'd be a very central character within the Newcomer community, and I love how you've integrated him into his new situation.

Also his tsun crochety awkwardness is very fun to play with. :3c

[proxysearch]

Hope Hope Hope Hope Hope you are always amazing for keeping up with so many diverse plots that Edgeworth's in. Your voicing is really wonderful and I'm always floored with your log tags and the thought you put into them.

Dolph, while new, definitely gave me a creeper vibe the other day when I saw him on someone's post. He was both polite and somewhat intruding and I could definitely see a quiet manipulation going on. If that was what you were going for, then keep up the good work! I would just like to see more of him.

[beenwaitinglong]

Hope, your Edgeworth is one of the consistent joys I get out of this game. He's absolutely wonderful and you work so hard with him. I love his and Diegodot's awkward buddy cop friendship and I've had so much fun working on the AGI stuff with you.

I hope there'll be much more of the two of them in the future!

[alwaysforhim]

HOPEYYY. You know how much I adore and admire you for Edgeworth alone-- the way he's mean without being hard-hearted, the way you can play out that balance of woobie and irritability, the way he's kind without being ooc-- ff, man, you play him amazingly, never forget that.

[troublesmells]

I always, always enjoy threading with Edgeworth. I always think OMG I'M THREADING WITH THE AMAZING HOPE AAAAAAA but seriously? He's very much IC and you really take the time to think up plots and so many other things, and Edgeworth really is as involved as he really would be in a place like this.

<3

[quackery]

I smile so hard whenever I get a tag from you, aaaaaa. Edgeworth's crabbiness is the most endearing, and I love Dolph's creeping from what I've seen. The level of involvement you have in this game is amaaaaazing c:

[gaveherwings]

I've really loved seeing Edgeworth finally pull this case together, I'm really excited to see him triumph over the odds and come into real conflict with corporate- and that you've been so fabulous in organizing the consequences of it, both systemically and in the AGI backlash. It isn't often that we get to see the AA lawyers spotlighted in doing the core of their thing, or many characters showing some potent in-game agency towards their convictions, so lemme just reiterate that I've been a fan all the way through this plot. It's also been fun seeing some personal relationships deepen with Edgeworth, as well as watching him abrasively burn other bridges.

Dolph has been incredibly fun to watch throughout his post, I'm thrilled that you've brought along someone with very dangerous principles, investigative and persuasive and questioning without being your average mwaha-villain. I love his polite method- it's so, so very well played. I'm excited to see more of him, I'm really excited that SERO has gained a subtle ally in him, and I can't

[grimmjerk]

FOREVER LOVE.