Alright, you yahoos,

[siren_of_psych]

Your task is to name the Broadway Musical from which this line is from, "Look, I made a hat where there never was a hat."
Your clues thus far:
Many Patinkin
Pointilism
The Chicago Art Institute
Brent Spiner
Broadway Musical

Your New Clue for 70 Points: (which can be traded in for steadily fading admiration)