Fishing Post

Jul 10, 2012 17:21



Read more... )

go fish! 2012

Leave a comment

Comments 12

esmeiolanthe July 10 2012, 23:21:29 UTC
What time period qualifies as "Historical Fiction"? There is much debate over this in library circles, with proposed definitions often including such factors as the age of the writer or the date when the story was written as compared to the date in which the story is set.

Reply

regacylady July 11 2012, 01:02:24 UTC
For the purposes of this challenge historical fiction will count as anything before or during WWII.

Reply

esmeiolanthe July 11 2012, 01:10:25 UTC
Awesome. Thanks! :)

Reply


scribal_goddess July 11 2012, 15:55:23 UTC
Noir counts as Action/Adventure if there are enough people shooting at the protagonist, right?

Reply

regacylady July 15 2012, 01:00:24 UTC
Absolutely. XD

Reply

scribal_goddess July 15 2012, 14:57:26 UTC
Yay!

Reply


esmeiolanthe July 11 2012, 23:21:11 UTC
Another question... What happens in the event of a tie?

Reply

regacylady July 15 2012, 01:01:59 UTC
Sorry about being slow to respond! In the event of a tie the winning option will be chosen at random through a virtual coin flip so the player is not delayed in beginning the challenge.

Reply

esmeiolanthe July 15 2012, 02:53:58 UTC
Okay, thanks. :) At least I won't have to try to combine the two genres!

Reply


esmeiolanthe July 15 2012, 21:05:12 UTC
One last question: "Urban Fantasy" is another slippery genre. What definition are the people in charge using? Some places say it has a kick-ass female protagonist. Some places say it has a tortured male protagonist. Some places say it just matters that it's set in a city. Some say it has to be Chicago/New York/LA. Some say it doesn't matter where it is, as long as it's a city that's practically a character in its own right, and some say the city doesn't need *that* much personality. Some say it has to be gritty; some say Charles de Lint writes urban fantasy, and *he's* not gritty at all...

I mean, what I'm thinking of is a story that *by my own personal standards* is darker, with a poorly-adjusted male protagonist who does in fact live in a city, but it's more of an alterna-urban-fantasy type thing. Does the "You can do anything you'd like, pretty much" cover that?

Sorry for asking so many questions! :(

Reply

regacylady July 15 2012, 21:22:30 UTC
No problem!

Urban Fantasy does not have to use a specific type of protagonist, and said protagonist does not have to be male or female. The only essential part is that it is set in an urban area, although in my opinion Urban Fantasy is more contemporary than High Fantasy.

However, as long as what you write is, in your honest opinion, fitting to the genre you are assigned that is all that is required.

Reply

esmeiolanthe July 16 2012, 00:08:26 UTC
OK, thanks. I'll get started tomorrow, just in case things change yet again.

Thanks for putting up with me!

Reply


Leave a comment

Up