02-10: Voting
Welcome to challenge 10 voting! Sorry for the delay. I was a bit distracted by Birth By Sleep and then I looked up and it was past time to post voting and I hadn't even gotten this post set up.
All three finalists have submitted. There will be no eliminations this week. The finalists will be competing for placement. The points they earned to get here are gone and voting is weighted, so please vote for all three sets.
rules
• don't vote for yourself or ask your friends to vote for you.
• vote for all 3 sets in your order of preference because votes are weighted.
• vote for your 3 favorite icons, order does not matter, these votes will receive 1 pt a piece.
• you must provide a 10+ word crit/comment/reason for your most favorite set and icon.
• you may provide comments/crits for all icons even if you don't vote them as your most favorite. you are not required to, it is completely optional, but highly recommended to help each other improve.
• participants should not vote, but they may leave crits for any sets or icons.
• please use this form to vote:
Set Placement
1st place (+3pts) SET X - crit
2nd place (+2pts) SET X - crit (optional)
3rd place (+1pt) SET X - crit (optional)
Favorite icon
SET X #00 f - crit
SET X #00 f - crit (optional)
SET X #00 f - crit (optional)
Additional crits
SET X #00 a - crit
(as many as you want - optional)
SET A010203
SET B010203
SET C010203
special notes:
Set A: Theme - Fullmetal Alchemist; challenges - 03, 04, 08
Set B: Theme - Bakumatsu Kikansetsu Irohanihoheto & textures; challenges - 02, 05, 07
Set C: Theme - Katekyo Hitman Reborn! similar composition to all the icons, 1 color + BW coloring; challenges - 03, 04, 09
[ submission post]
Voting ends in 48 hours - 12:00am PDT Monday September 13th. (late Sunday night). [current time]
All three finalists have submitted. There will be no eliminations this week. The finalists will be competing for placement. The points they earned to get here are gone and voting is weighted, so please vote for all three sets.
rules
• don't vote for yourself or ask your friends to vote for you.
• vote for all 3 sets in your order of preference because votes are weighted.
• vote for your 3 favorite icons, order does not matter, these votes will receive 1 pt a piece.
• you must provide a 10+ word crit/comment/reason for your most favorite set and icon.
• you may provide comments/crits for all icons even if you don't vote them as your most favorite. you are not required to, it is completely optional, but highly recommended to help each other improve.
• participants should not vote, but they may leave crits for any sets or icons.
• please use this form to vote:
Set Placement
1st place (+3pts) SET X - crit
2nd place (+2pts) SET X - crit (optional)
3rd place (+1pt) SET X - crit (optional)
Favorite icon
SET X #00 f - crit
SET X #00 f - crit (optional)
SET X #00 f - crit (optional)
Additional crits
SET X #00 a - crit
(as many as you want - optional)
SET A010203
SET B010203
SET C010203
special notes:
Set A: Theme - Fullmetal Alchemist; challenges - 03, 04, 08
Set B: Theme - Bakumatsu Kikansetsu Irohanihoheto & textures; challenges - 02, 05, 07
Set C: Theme - Katekyo Hitman Reborn! similar composition to all the icons, 1 color + BW coloring; challenges - 03, 04, 09
[ submission post]
Voting ends in 48 hours - 12:00am PDT Monday September 13th. (late Sunday night). [current time]