For those who doesn't know, Once Upon a Pirate Night didn't made the Broadway cut, being replaced in the early stages of Spring Awakening Off Broadway cut. But I think it's prettier than There Was Once a Pirate and even... The Guilty Ones. So, I found the link on google and it's SO BEAUTIFUL. Totally worth the download :)
From FuckyeahStBerry
Lyrics
Once upon a pirate night
By a moon so full and pale
A maiden took a treasure ride
With the boy she knew to help the sail
Melchior:
A murmur of something oh, so fair
A door through he yearning there, just there
Untie the rope to bring her close
To wind and water everywhere
Both:
And soon they can't resist the tide
The pull of something long denied
All that pleasure out of reach
Little there and oh so sweet
In some frightened happy pasttime
Soon they found and only there
They bade their hearts with ageless wisdom
As she whispers "Yes" again
All:
And as you ride the salty air
A new world to discover
A world with care not to bare
Wendla:
And now she's found a lover
Melchior:
Somehow he's found a lover
All:
And now she's found a love
LINK TO DOWNLOAD I wish I had a chance to see this :(