So is it my male chauvinism showing or is it completely ridiculous that they've replaced Christopher Robin with a girl in the new Winnie the Pooh movie?
Part of me thinks "Eh, there's nothing essentially male about Christopher Robin; I don't see a problem with a bit of revision that doesn't touch the essence of the character".
The rest of me pretty much agrees with Neil Gaiman's take on the subject, and remembers that it's not that Christopher Robin's character is being altered, it's that he's being replaced whole-cloth with another character that completely lacks the point of the story. The entire reason behind his character is that he's a quiet little boy that prefers playing in his room with his stuffed animals to having any human interaction; it gives Milne's original stories a faint melancholy that Disney has finally finished completely stripping away.
I think it's utterly ridiculous, but only because it's totally arbitrary. There's no plausible justification for the change.
It's like replacing Michelangelo with Andy Warhol in "The Agony and the Ecstasy" because someone thought it would make a more entertaining story. Though a pop culture Sistine Chapel might be amusing to see.
Want to find Carnival Game Rental Los Angeles?
anonymous
January 11 2011, 23:14:12 UTC
Livelihood in the Capital has it's advantages nevertheless similar with all stuff, there certainly is of course a draw back also! Dwelling in the heart of the act is essential, once you should be in the circle. My chief, Justin, continually talks about this. Actually, he spends the better part of the daytime to think around things like the problem. Still, for my friends Emile, Lorene along with Jc, the City is the solitary area to be alive. For me this urban living is brilliant! I need not drop in on the clubs. I quite desire a great Hangar Festivity and with the information of [url=http://boomerevents.com/index.php]Carnival Game Rental Los Angeles[/url] it is always a rare happening! Life needs us furthermore all of us require from time to time a little crucial amusement, to be able to keep up in the midst of our day by day hassle!! I am Zane Vang and I wish your coming celebration will be a hit!
Feed to rental business software?
anonymous
January 14 2011, 19:21:30 UTC
At the time of my last journey toward San Marino I stumbled over Galen while on the path. He advised my person, he was free to get a brand new Software package here the Notebook Depot at this area. Well, what a luck, I was just on the way to be off to this same shop, nevertheless for a different purpose. We both decided that we depart organized, hence we both can present counsel to each other
( ... )
Comments 5
And, yes, it IS ridiculous and stupid that they replaced Christopher Robin with a girl.
Reply
The rest of me pretty much agrees with Neil Gaiman's take on the subject, and remembers that it's not that Christopher Robin's character is being altered, it's that he's being replaced whole-cloth with another character that completely lacks the point of the story. The entire reason behind his character is that he's a quiet little boy that prefers playing in his room with his stuffed animals to having any human interaction; it gives Milne's original stories a faint melancholy that Disney has finally finished completely stripping away.
Reply
It's like replacing Michelangelo with Andy Warhol in "The Agony and the Ecstasy" because someone thought it would make a more entertaining story. Though a pop culture Sistine Chapel might be amusing to see.
Reply
Life needs us furthermore all of us require from time to time a little crucial amusement, to be able to keep up in the midst of our day by day hassle!!
I am Zane Vang and I wish your coming celebration will be a hit!
Reply
Reply
Leave a comment