RESULTS FOR LFWS #1 ROUND 12
All votes are counted and voting for the Last Fic Writer Standing Challenge 1 Round 12 is closed. All authors are now revealed and the feedback to the individual posts are unscreened. These fics are now released to be posted elsewhere by the respective authors.
The First Place winner for this round is rhymer23 with < PARALLEL LIVES and a score of +4.
Mod's Choice goes to wildcat88 with RENDZEVOUS WITH DESTINY and a score of +3. She wrote a a very well written story about the pilot side of Sheppard that we don't often see with this graphic detail in SGA, also diving into the idea that Sheppard had already faced hard situations before in his career. The ending added a valuable piece of information about the character, working with what he was at the beginning, a jet pilot, to the new man he became later, a chopper pilot that goes behind the lines to save downed men.
Congratulations to all! Your banners are being made by highonstargate. highonstargate remember to link the banner as a screened comment in the voting post, and not to this post, because here the comments are unscreened. We’ll not hotlink your art.
Unfortunately, barcardicider received the lowest score and will be leaving the LFWS #1. You can join the next challenge when sign ups open.
Scores:
RENDZEVOUS WITH DESTINY was written by wildcat88 (+1, -1, -1, +1, +1, +1, +1 = +3)
PARALLEL LIVES was written by rhymer23 (+1, +1, +1, +1, -1, +1= +4)
LOST AND FOUND was written by kristen999 (-1, -1= -2)
HOPE was written by barcardicider (-1, -1, -1, +1, -1, -1, -1, -1= -6)
SENSE OF THE ART was written by linziday (+1, -1, -1, +1, +1, -1, +1= +1)
If you want to receive the criticism for your story just leave a comment. The mods will post all the criticism in a screened comment to your request. You can have the criticism unscreened if you want to share it with other writers, but you can keep them a secret if you want.
Next prompt will be posted in a few moments.
The First Place winner for this round is rhymer23 with < PARALLEL LIVES and a score of +4.
Mod's Choice goes to wildcat88 with RENDZEVOUS WITH DESTINY and a score of +3. She wrote a a very well written story about the pilot side of Sheppard that we don't often see with this graphic detail in SGA, also diving into the idea that Sheppard had already faced hard situations before in his career. The ending added a valuable piece of information about the character, working with what he was at the beginning, a jet pilot, to the new man he became later, a chopper pilot that goes behind the lines to save downed men.
Congratulations to all! Your banners are being made by highonstargate. highonstargate remember to link the banner as a screened comment in the voting post, and not to this post, because here the comments are unscreened. We’ll not hotlink your art.
Unfortunately, barcardicider received the lowest score and will be leaving the LFWS #1. You can join the next challenge when sign ups open.
Scores:
RENDZEVOUS WITH DESTINY was written by wildcat88 (+1, -1, -1, +1, +1, +1, +1 = +3)
PARALLEL LIVES was written by rhymer23 (+1, +1, +1, +1, -1, +1= +4)
LOST AND FOUND was written by kristen999 (-1, -1= -2)
HOPE was written by barcardicider (-1, -1, -1, +1, -1, -1, -1, -1= -6)
SENSE OF THE ART was written by linziday (+1, -1, -1, +1, +1, -1, +1= +1)
If you want to receive the criticism for your story just leave a comment. The mods will post all the criticism in a screened comment to your request. You can have the criticism unscreened if you want to share it with other writers, but you can keep them a secret if you want.
Next prompt will be posted in a few moments.