Elimination 8/1
Sadly we have to say goodbye to:
bluejello
with - 7 votes
I hope you'll be back for the next round!
Favorite icon:
jhava
Votes in total:
Notice: If there are positive and negative votes for the same icon, the positive ones will be added to the negative ones. If your icon number is not listed you didn't receive any votes.
3. daughterofeve47: -4
4. mischief5 : -3
5. tomo_p: +1 -2 = -1
6. collswan: -1
7. bluejello: -7
8. vickysg1: +1
9. azangal_icons: +2 -1 = +1
10. jhava: +3 -1 = +2
11. acari: +1 -5 = -4
Comments:
03 - the coloring is too dark on the foreground figure as compared to the overbrightened coloring on the background texture.
03 - the effect makes the background color stand out real well, but makes John a little to darkened
03 - The image of Sheppard seems too dark and the trees are uninteresting. Also, the two images seem out of proportion to each other.
03 - john looks just out and pasted back into the icon but the color of the trees doesnt complement the lighting on him.
04 - background is too plain and could use a bit more contrast
04 - Imo the blue background doesn't fit the situation and isn't really supportive
04 - John looks a bit flat. A bit more contrast would have helped that.
05 - The blue light doesn't really fit and makes it next to impossible to read the text.
05 - the blue light texture is out of place
06 - the spot of lightening on Ronon's face makes the coloring look uneven
07 - The crop focuses in on Ronon's sword, which could work except that the sword is hard to make out through the effect used and is over-sharpened.
07 - the icon is over sharpened
07 - The icon is way too sharp, making it very pixelated.
07 - the image is oversharpened and the coloring is overly brown.
07 - this is a little oversharpened, but I like the color chosen for use with Ronon
07 - Too grainy, colours are not complementing the icon
07 - the picture is washed out and grainy
09 - the image of John is slightly oversharpened and there's too much contrast between his face and the background
10 - the blue background doesn't fit the situation and isn't really supportive
11 - Although I like the light effect, Sheppard's face seems over-sharpened.
11 - over-lightened and a little blurry
11 - the icon is too light and the colors are all over the place
11 - Too light, not enough contrast
11 - the color is washed out making the faces look overexposed
Favorites:
05
08 - I like the use of the text and the way it adds to the action feel of the icon.
09 - gorgeous lighting and background texture, the B&W makes it outstanding
09 - nice use of contrast
10 - Nice crop and the way the background helps the focus is great.
10 - the blending into the background is perfectly done and the texture is the perfect contrast to ronon making all the colors go together
10 - i really like how this icon captures and emphasis Ronon's dynamic motion
11 - lovely use of texture and good cropping and coloring.
bluejello
with - 7 votes
I hope you'll be back for the next round!
Favorite icon:
jhava
Votes in total:
Notice: If there are positive and negative votes for the same icon, the positive ones will be added to the negative ones. If your icon number is not listed you didn't receive any votes.
3. daughterofeve47: -4
4. mischief5 : -3
5. tomo_p: +1 -2 = -1
6. collswan: -1
7. bluejello: -7
8. vickysg1: +1
9. azangal_icons: +2 -1 = +1
10. jhava: +3 -1 = +2
11. acari: +1 -5 = -4
Comments:
03 - the coloring is too dark on the foreground figure as compared to the overbrightened coloring on the background texture.
03 - the effect makes the background color stand out real well, but makes John a little to darkened
03 - The image of Sheppard seems too dark and the trees are uninteresting. Also, the two images seem out of proportion to each other.
03 - john looks just out and pasted back into the icon but the color of the trees doesnt complement the lighting on him.
04 - background is too plain and could use a bit more contrast
04 - Imo the blue background doesn't fit the situation and isn't really supportive
04 - John looks a bit flat. A bit more contrast would have helped that.
05 - The blue light doesn't really fit and makes it next to impossible to read the text.
05 - the blue light texture is out of place
06 - the spot of lightening on Ronon's face makes the coloring look uneven
07 - The crop focuses in on Ronon's sword, which could work except that the sword is hard to make out through the effect used and is over-sharpened.
07 - the icon is over sharpened
07 - The icon is way too sharp, making it very pixelated.
07 - the image is oversharpened and the coloring is overly brown.
07 - this is a little oversharpened, but I like the color chosen for use with Ronon
07 - Too grainy, colours are not complementing the icon
07 - the picture is washed out and grainy
09 - the image of John is slightly oversharpened and there's too much contrast between his face and the background
10 - the blue background doesn't fit the situation and isn't really supportive
11 - Although I like the light effect, Sheppard's face seems over-sharpened.
11 - over-lightened and a little blurry
11 - the icon is too light and the colors are all over the place
11 - Too light, not enough contrast
11 - the color is washed out making the faces look overexposed
Favorites:
05
08 - I like the use of the text and the way it adds to the action feel of the icon.
09 - gorgeous lighting and background texture, the B&W makes it outstanding
09 - nice use of contrast
10 - Nice crop and the way the background helps the focus is great.
10 - the blending into the background is perfectly done and the texture is the perfect contrast to ronon making all the colors go together
10 - i really like how this icon captures and emphasis Ronon's dynamic motion
11 - lovely use of texture and good cropping and coloring.