Elimination 7/4
Sadly we have to say goodbye to:
tomo_p
with - 4 votes
I hope you'll be back for the next round!
Favorite icon:
jhava
Votes in total:
Notice: If there are positive and negative votes for the same icon, the positive ones will be added to the negative ones. If your icon number is not listed you didn't receive any votes.
1. tomo_p: -4
2. jenniferjensen: +1 -3 = -2
3. immortalje: -2
4. collswan: +2 -1 = +1
5. jhava: +2
6. overreact: -2
7. ender839: +2 -2 = 0
Comments:
01 - a little too contrasted
01 - icon is dark and the colour just doesn't seem right.
01 - The crop is uninteresting.
01 - The skin tone is too yellow.
02 - The crop makes it look a bit like the aspect ratio is off in the image. There's also not much depth of contrast in Caldwell's face, which lets the eye wander away from the icon.
02 - Caldwell appears overly blurry in consideration of the size of the crop the coloring is very washed out -- some depth would help to pop out the Caldwell figure from the background.
02 - the icon seems really empty. the crop just feels really unbalanced.
03 - the crop is very basic and doesn't accent any particular element of the character.
03 - unoriginal cropping
04 - There isn't a lot of dynamic contrast in the icon - the darks and lights don't 'pop' out when looking at the icon.
06 - coloring seems faded
06 - Not much seems to have been done to the photo.
07 - not enough contrast
07 - The icon could have used a bit more contrast and it's a bit too sharp. Additionally, the coloured area at the top distracts from the text and the person.
Favorites:
02 - The crop works really well.
04 - cap was lightened well. simple. pretty.
04 - The text works well without overpowering the icon, and the colouring is both creative and pleasing to the eye.
05 - nice coloring and good use of text
05 - The coloring is pretty good - the background and text totally make the icon work, though. Good work!
07 - like the B&W with the lighting effect
07 - lovely contrast of black and white to the coloured texture in the background.
tomo_p
with - 4 votes
I hope you'll be back for the next round!
Favorite icon:
jhava
Votes in total:
Notice: If there are positive and negative votes for the same icon, the positive ones will be added to the negative ones. If your icon number is not listed you didn't receive any votes.
1. tomo_p: -4
2. jenniferjensen: +1 -3 = -2
3. immortalje: -2
4. collswan: +2 -1 = +1
5. jhava: +2
6. overreact: -2
7. ender839: +2 -2 = 0
Comments:
01 - a little too contrasted
01 - icon is dark and the colour just doesn't seem right.
01 - The crop is uninteresting.
01 - The skin tone is too yellow.
02 - The crop makes it look a bit like the aspect ratio is off in the image. There's also not much depth of contrast in Caldwell's face, which lets the eye wander away from the icon.
02 - Caldwell appears overly blurry in consideration of the size of the crop the coloring is very washed out -- some depth would help to pop out the Caldwell figure from the background.
02 - the icon seems really empty. the crop just feels really unbalanced.
03 - the crop is very basic and doesn't accent any particular element of the character.
03 - unoriginal cropping
04 - There isn't a lot of dynamic contrast in the icon - the darks and lights don't 'pop' out when looking at the icon.
06 - coloring seems faded
06 - Not much seems to have been done to the photo.
07 - not enough contrast
07 - The icon could have used a bit more contrast and it's a bit too sharp. Additionally, the coloured area at the top distracts from the text and the person.
Favorites:
02 - The crop works really well.
04 - cap was lightened well. simple. pretty.
04 - The text works well without overpowering the icon, and the colouring is both creative and pleasing to the eye.
05 - nice coloring and good use of text
05 - The coloring is pretty good - the background and text totally make the icon work, though. Good work!
07 - like the B&W with the lighting effect
07 - lovely contrast of black and white to the coloured texture in the background.