Voting: Round 3 // Challenge 6: sg1

hsapiens in sg1_lims

Voting: Round 3 // Challenge 6

Nov 17, 2009 20:23

Using a skip this week:
colls, ctofine, ender839, own_the_sky, silentsarah, tiah15

Disqualified due to non-participation:
forensicirulan, sasusc, veronica_a

You guys amaze me yet again. This will be another difficult vote. So many great icons, so few MF votes.

VOTING

You must vote for four icons: your two (2) least favorite (the entries you consider to be of lesser quality in technique) and your two (2) favorite (the entries you consider to be the best).
You must provide a reason for ALL of your votes.
Please remember that you are judging on technique shown in making an icon. Voting should never be based on your personal character, pairing, or team preferences. "Text is ugly" is not a constructive comment; "Text is too formal for an icon that is humorous," is.
Whether an icon fits the week's cap theme is irrelevant and should not be used as a basis for voting.
Only the votes complying with the above rules will be counted.
If you have any questions at all about what qualifies as a constructive comment or any other topic, please don't hesitate to contact either beeej or me. You may private message me here on LJ at any time.

Code to copy & paste into a comment for voting:

LEAST FAVORITE
##: (Reason goes here)
##: (Reason goes here)

MOST FAVORITE
##: (Reason goes here)
##: (Reason goes here)

For a further look at the voting rules, see this comm's user info. Please remember anyone can -- and is encouraged to! -- vote. Comments are screened.

001