"What Jedi Feud?"
"WHAT JEDI FEUD?"
For over two decades, many STAR WARS fans have claimed that the franchise's prequel characters Anakin Skywalker (the future Darth Vader) and Jedi Master Mace Windu were constantly at odds during the three Prequel Trilogy movies. I find this claim very difficult to accept. Why? Because I never saw any real evidence of this.
The trilogy's first movie, "STAR WARS: EPISODE I - THE PHANTOM MENACE" established not only the existence of the Jedi Order, it also established Jedi Master Yoda and Mace Windu as the Council and Order's top leaders. After his connection to the Force was tested, the Council rejected him as one of the Order's future acolytes. I cannot deny that Master Windu proved to the one member who informed both nine-year-old Anakin and his sponsor Jedi Master Qui-Gon Jinn that the former would not be accepted within the Jedi Order. But I believe many fans had failed to realize that Mace was not solely responsible for the Council's rejection of Anakin. He had made this decision along with the entire Jedi Council. Mace had merely expressed what they had decided. I have grave doubts that the Council would allow Mace to be the only one to decide upon Anakin joining the Order. What would be the point of the Order existing in the first place? Even in the following movie, "STAR WARS: EPISODE II - ATTACK OF THE CLONES", both Mace and Yoda had discussed the Order's diminishing connection to the Force. Although Mace had suggested they inform the Galactic Senate of the situation, it was Yoda who made the final decision to keep it a secret. So much for Mace Windu being the sole decision-maker of the Jedi Council.
In "THE PHANTOM MENACE", the Jedi Council had sensed Anakin's connection to the Force due to his actions during the Battle of Naboo. Because of this, the Council had reversed its decision and allowed Anakin to join the Order. Only one Council member proved to be the sole voice of dissent . . . and it was not Mace Windu. Actually, Yoda proved to be the only Council member who did not want Anakin to join the Order, fearing the nine-year-old would prove to be a future threat. Yoda also disapproved of former Jedi padawan-turned-Knight Obi-Wan Kenobi becoming Anakin's new Jedi tutor. Realizing he was seriously outvoted, Yoda finally changed his vote in order to align with his fellow Council members. But there is no denying that Yoda proved to be the last holdout against allowing Anakin into the Order.
Another reason why I find it difficult to believe that Master Windu had been in conflict with Anakin throughout the Prequel Trilogy was his conversation with Obi-Wan in one of the scenes from "ATTACK OF THE CLONES". During a stroll with Obi-Wan inside the Jedi Temple, the latter had accused Anakin of growing arrogant about his abilities. He also expressed doubt about the Chosen One prophecy. Mace, who seemed opened to the latter, had expressed surprise at Obi-Wan’s negative attitude toward Anakin. Yoda joined in the conversation. Although the latter remained silent about the Chosen One prophecy, he expressed a warning that many of the Order's members had been growing increasingly arrogant lately.
I can only recall one Prequel Trilogy in which Master Windu had expressed open hostility toward Anakin. Before the release of the trilogy's third film, "REVENGE OF THE SITH", George Lucas had sanctioned the creation of the 2005 novel, "Labyrinth of Evil", which served as a direct prequel to the 2005 movie. Written by James Lucerno and released four months before "REVENGE OF THE SITH", Lucerno's novel featured Count Dooku aka Darth Tyrannus' capture of the Galactic Republic Chancellor Sheev Palpatine. The novel also featured the Jedi Council's discovery that someone within the Chancellor's circle had connections to Dooku and another Sith Lord.
This discovery had led to the Jedi Council's growing distrust and hostility toward Anakin, due to his friendship with Palpatine. With the exception of Obi-Wan, whose attitude toward Anakin and the prophecy had changed after three years, other members of the Council had more or less began expressing a distant or cold attitude toward the 22-year-old knight - including Mace Windu. When Obi-Wan had suggested that Anakin spy on Chancellor Palpatine on behalf of the Council, the younger man rebuffed the idea in anger. However, Anakin was not the only one who had protested against the plan. Both Yoda and Windu also questioned Obi-Wan's plan. Mace openly admitted that he did not trust Anakin. Yoda went even further and questioned the plausibility of the Chosen One prophecy. For their own reasons, both Windu AND Yoda had simply refused to trust Anakin or believe in the prophecy.
Which leads me to this question . . . why do so many fans still claim that Mace Windu had been hostile toward Anakin Skywalker throughout the entire Prequel Trilogy? Why do so many of them, to this day, want to believe that the Jedi Master and Jedi Knight had a feud? It seemed quite obvious that Anakin had problems with the Order at different occasions - even with his own Jedi Master, Obi-Wan Kenobi. Yet, many fans have turned a blind eye to this and decided that Mace Windu . . . and no one else, had been in conflict with Anakin. Is this some attempt by fans to blame Master Windu for Anakin's downfall? I hope not. Anyone with common sense could see that Anakin's relationship with the Order and specifically, members of the Council, had been a lot more complicated.
I might as well make this plain. I have never seen any one-on-one conflict between Anakin Skywalker and Master Mace Windu on the movie or television screens. Not in the Prequel Trilogy movies or in "THE CLONE WARS" animated series. So, why is it still important for fans to believe that a feud between the pair had existed?