Round #4 // Challenge #2
Skipping : i_we_you
Rules
Vote for 2 lesser icons and you must give a reason.
Vote for the general quality of the image, cropping, coloring, text placement, etc. Not simply because it isn't a style you would normally use and therefore you dislike it. Personal reasons like 'I don't like the color blue' are not acceptable. Try to avoid "I don't like..."
Don't say for example...
"The icon is awkward and/or weird looking." or "I hate that font, its fugly!"
We want reasons like...
"Too blurry." or "Oversharpened." or "The coloring makes the person look green."
Also vote for 2 favorite icons, reasons are not a must, but it would be nice.
Don't vote for yourself! The vote won't count. And you'll make a kitten cry.
Anyone can vote! Yay! No anon voting though. Comments will be screened.
Voting will end late Thursday night!
Sample Voting Format
LF: number - reason required
LF: number - reason required
F: number - reason optional
F: number - reason optional
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Rules
Vote for 2 lesser icons and you must give a reason.
Vote for the general quality of the image, cropping, coloring, text placement, etc. Not simply because it isn't a style you would normally use and therefore you dislike it. Personal reasons like 'I don't like the color blue' are not acceptable. Try to avoid "I don't like..."
Don't say for example...
"The icon is awkward and/or weird looking." or "I hate that font, its fugly!"
We want reasons like...
"Too blurry." or "Oversharpened." or "The coloring makes the person look green."
Also vote for 2 favorite icons, reasons are not a must, but it would be nice.
Don't vote for yourself! The vote won't count. And you'll make a kitten cry.
Anyone can vote! Yay! No anon voting though. Comments will be screened.
Voting will end late Thursday night!
Sample Voting Format
LF: number - reason required
LF: number - reason required
F: number - reason optional
F: number - reason optional
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8