Leave a comment

steepholm March 2 2015, 17:14:23 UTC
Oh dear - another case of Atwood's Elbow?

Reply

sartorias March 2 2015, 17:15:17 UTC
I'm getting that impression from her words.

Reply

steepholm March 2 2015, 17:16:54 UTC
And here's a review quoted in the latest Ansible:

'It would be too easy to call what Ishiguro is undertaking "fantasy" or "magical realism." Critics will summon such phrases to describe this book, but they would be wrong to do so. Such facile labels - suggesting that the author is relying on literary devices pulled from old bags of tricks - have no meaning here. Instead, what we are given in The Buried Giant has the clear ring of legend, original and humane as anything Ishiguro has written.' (Marie Arana, Washington Post, 25 February)

Heigh ho.

Reply

sartorias March 2 2015, 17:27:55 UTC
Interesting!

Reply

hand2hand March 2 2015, 22:40:21 UTC
OK, so LEGEND is good? FANTASY is bad?

I'm so confused.

Reply

sartorias March 2 2015, 23:41:25 UTC
'genre' is the polyester pantsuit of literary fashion. 'Fantasy' spells 'genre.'

Reply


Leave a comment

Up