One Piece 51

Sep 21, 2014 14:44

Shabondy, yay! This is one of those arcs (kind of like Jaya, vols 24-25) that can be overwhelming at first and is probably better on a re-read, but even on a first read, it is still made of multiple layers of awesome.

Volume 51: Eleven Supernovas )

one piece

Leave a comment

sara_tanaquil October 5 2014, 14:10:20 UTC
Whee, long comments! I love it when you have time to do these.

Like…pirate hunter turned superpirate or something? The pirate code?

Zoro is totally a pirate samurai!

Haki?

Ding ding ding! It won't be more fully explained for a while though. (That bison looks too traumatized to be in love. Although, Luffy is really good at winning over animal pets.)

I totally don't get the winking joke. Is this something sparkly guys do in manga that I haven't noticed?

I guess? Honestly I don't get it if it's supposed to be a specific cultural reference, I just think it's hilarious that poor Duval is still 100% dork behind the new pretty face. (We like you that way, Duval. Never change!) And also the way his face kind of shatters when he tries to do the winking thing.

Thank you for fixing Viz's translation.

I did think Viz missed the boat a bit there. It was a subtle difference, but there was something so poignant about Chopper assuming that he couldn't go because Keimi couldn't. Kind of like a child's-eye view of racism.

(In Viz' defense: I caught about a dozen errors in my own summary through reading the English. It is just amazing, the amount of stuff I can screw up.)

I'm going to be sacrilegious and say I think it was poorly done. I mean, I like that it's there, but given how it's picked up later, it needed to be more obvious.

I would agree with you except for the fact that One Piece fans are insane. I've started reading discussion boards for the current manga chapter, and the details that people pick out to comment on, you would not believe. I sometimes think Oda plants things just for the insane people.

Shakky and Robin need to meet.

I'm convinced Robin will BE Shakky when she's older. (Shakky is awesome!)

Somebody is, because that page is torn out of my library copy. I thought you were ff'ing to the auction house. I missed Law's Oda-box! *pout*

Nooooo! I mean, yay Trafalgar fans, but BOO to desecrating library books. That's pretty low.

It links to a scanlation, but Trafalgar page:

http://i15.mangapanda.com/one-piece/498/one-piece-1693879.jpg

And the back of the page, which must have been missing as well - I guess you didn't see Urouge and Killer's boxes?

http://i8.mangapanda.com/one-piece/498/one-piece-1693876.jpg

Hee! Only part of this cover arc I like. LET LUCCI DIE.

Not that I have any deep investment in Lucci's survival, but I did kind of love how the whole group pulled together for him (even if he doesn't deserve it). [ETA because I accidentally commented on something from the next volume, ignore spoilers!]

About Kidd and whom?

The main one I'm thinking of is an epic Kidd/Law fanfic which is still ongoing (and it's actually surprisingly good), but slave-fic in general is distressingly popular, and this provides the perfect in-canon departure point for it.

The moment they revelaed the slave auction was in grove 1, my only thought was that Oda is a genius.

You are so smart! I didn't anticipate that at all.

So much plot to drop on top of needing to rescue Camie and kick some world noble butt and meet 9 other superpirates.

No kidding! One Piece demands an awful lot from its readers.

Speaking of which - I mentioned at the top of the post on 52 that 52 ends in a cliffhanger, which it does, but I forgot until I started working on 53 that 53 doesn't really help. You could go on to 54, but then there's *spoiler* which leads to *spoiler*, and honestly the best plan is to get used to being in suspense until volume 60 or so. I will try not to take two years to get through the summaries. (Two years! Oda is a cruel master.)

Reply

suffire December 20 2014, 01:36:10 UTC
I apologize for randomly coming in here, but I'm in the process of re-reading OP as well, and just found my way to these summaries, I am really enjoying reading these!

Reply

sara_tanaquil December 20 2014, 02:04:03 UTC
Yay for new friends/readers! I am in a bit of a lull right now because end of semester/holidays, but hoping to get back on track with volume 57 shortly.

Reply

suffire December 23 2014, 05:39:52 UTC
It's wonderful reading your comments and realize how much information I'm missing due to the fact that I do not speak Japanese, mostly all the ridiculous puns and some of the character tidbits, now I really do wish I can read Japanese!

Reply


Leave a comment

Up