Voting: 1.05 The Five

[regularamanda]

Choosing to use their skip this round: iwishiwerekerry and luckiestxclover.

I'll be withdrawing this round. Also, I've added a new rule so please be sure to see that at the bottom of the rules for voting in this post.

Here's the voting for 1.05, sorry for the delay! :) I'm going to wait to post the submission post for 1.06 until the winners are announced but don't forget to check the sidebar for the link to those pictures. Also, if there's an icon(s) you'd really like to comment on but it didn't make one of your favorites, you may still comment on it after you've voted for Least favorite/Most favorite!

• You are voting for four icons, two icons of your least favorite (lesser quality) and two icons of your most favorite (best quality).
• You MUST give a reason for each of your choices. You are voting on technique so please make sure to make it constructive feedback!
• Avoid using I think... and please try to answer the question 'why?' if you think it's oversharpened, instead of saying I think it's oversharpened. say something like The icon is oversharpened around her face and distracts from the overall concept of the icon. If it does not meet these standards, I may ask you to rephrase your reason, if it's not rephrased, I will not count the vote.
• All comments are screened so if you have any questions, feel free to let me know! Also you may still vote even if you aren't signed up for this round, however there is no anonymous voting.
• Please do NOT vote on if the icon fits the theme or not, focus on the quality of the icon.
• Voting is through Friday March 19rd.
• Please use the form below to vote.

LEAST FAVORITES
##:(reason)
##:(reason)
MOST FAVORITES
##:(reason)
##:(reason)

12345




67