Review: the pilot ep of 'Elementary'

Sep 30, 2012 01:04

9.5 of 10. Excellent pilot. the series should be quite something to behold.

This time, I'll be looking at the Top Five things in this episode, starting with the thing I hated most, to the part I loved the best.

#5. In the introductory scenes, Holmes says to Watson that line about a monkey. My first thought was fairly incoherent, my second was "why you little...!"

...and my third thought was a video-in-my-mind of Ancient Mai saying, while wounded and tired, "I'm not a trained monkey."

#4. When Holmes and Watson were in the observation room, watching the husband be interrogated, and Holmes turns to look at Watson, and he says something that startles her -- in the previews and commercials, my Closed Captioning, when it bothered to caption that, said [SPEAKS FOREIGN LANGUAGE], and his words sounded to my ears like "goo-goo" or "goh-guh".

Turns out, he said "Google. I don't observe everything." maybe i need to look into hearing aids again.

#3. The way Captain Gregson had already known (of) Holmes. I had been wondering how that would be handled, before Gregson explained it, and his version makes sense.

#2. Watson's love of baseball, and making Holmes watch it with her.
(though now we know Sherlock's a dangerous person to let watch a game)

#1. Dr. Joan Watson's little and not-so-little victories against Holmes, mostly in the forms of either questions ("how do you know I didn't leave them in a coma?") and deductions ("it was a woman" who made him leave London)

and an honorable mention to...Holmes' repeated - and inventive - apologies to Watson.

elementary, sherlock holmes, dresden files, episode, dr joan watson, episode review, review, watson, holmes

Previous post Next post
Up