01-05 VOTING

[astrokittie]

Only... two days late. I'm an idiot and forgot to check submissions closely so I had to ask a few people to remake some icons. So sorry about that! I thought it was only fair that I wait for them though. Here's the voting for the final challenge! I'm letting you all pick one extra favourite icon this week because there's so many awesome entries and it is our last challenge!
There were two skips this week: Princess Kraehe and Yui

voting info
Welcome to voting for round one challenge five at Rockin' Rumble! This week you will be voting for 5 most favourite and 2 least favourite icons. Order does not matter, but it would help me if a bunch if you put your votes in numerical order!

• Critiques for least favourite votes are mandatory, while critiques for favourite votes are optional. (but very much appreciated!)
• You will gain an additional two bonus points through voting and are you only eligible for People's Choice if you vote!
• Do not vote for yourself
• Critiques should be at least ten words each. A wonderful LIMS/Rumble voting tutorial can be found here if you're still not sure how to leave a proper critique. :3

Identity: (if you are a participant)

Favorite icons:
#xx + optional critique
#xx + optional critique
#xx + optional critique
#xx + optional critique
#xx + optional critique

Least favorite icons:
#xx - mandatory critique
#xx - mandatory critique

General comments (optional)
#xx G optional comment
(add as many if you want)

Challenge information is here. Don't forget to check out the original images (linked in the icon numbers) to see the the incredible transformation in each icon! You can hover over the icons to see character/series info.

1
2
3
4
5











6
7
8
9
10











11
12
13
14









Comments are screened and voting will be closed Tuesday, August 23rd at 11:00 PM PST.