02-01 RESULTS
UGH FINALLY. Sorry this took so long! Was sewing and playing with bunnies all day. At least the comments pages aren't killing my head today.
02-01: results
main challenge
people's choice
#7 with 11 points.
pc runner up
#13 with 10 points.
mod's choice
#05
I've been in love with this icon from the second it popped up in my inbox! The use of the provided texture is absolutely stunning, and it blends with the text so well. My only issue is that Zelda looks a bit sharp around the edges?
bonus challenge
people's choice
#4 with 12 points.
pc runner up (tie)
#3 & #6 with 10 points each.
mod's choice
#1
I adore this icon! I like how it's not cluttered with textures, which allows the typography to shine!
02-01: tallies
If there is a / in your tally, the number after it stands for the additional critiques that were not worth any points. B stands for bonus icon.
01 +2 (+4, -2)/2
02 -7 (+0, -7)/1 B: +2/1
03 +6 (+7, -1)/1
04 -2 (+3, -5)/2
05 +7 (+9, -2) B: +11
06 +9 (+9, -0) B: +12
07 +11 (+11, -0) B: +1/2
08 +5 (+6, -1)/1 B: +11
09 -7 (+0, -7)/3
10 -10 (+0, -10)/1 B: +2/1
11 -2 (+1, -3)/1 B: +5
12 -6 (+0, -6)/1
13 10 (+10, -0)/1
Rankings are here.
LOOOOL PROBABLY NOT TONIGHT. I have a busy day (AGAIN! And it's not even because we're celebrating the goddamn holidays! Our tree isn't even up ahahahaha OTZ) tomorrow and I should go to bed pretty soon, and I haven't even bothered to keep track of who promoted yet, so I'll sort all of the rankings out tomorrow.
If you would like your critiques, please reply to this post with your identity and/or your icon's number. I will reply to it with a screened post, so please make sure you have notifications turned on!
I can PM or email you your crits instead, or I can leave them unscreened if you would like, just let me know.
Be sure to keep your identity secret and don't promote your icons until the round is over!
The third challenge is already up and can be found here! Two of you have already submitted! ♥
EDIT: I've responded to all crits as of 12/22 at 11:15 PM PST, and a few of you notified me of LJ having not emailing comments to you, so let me know if you haven't gotten anything and I can PM your critiques to you.
02-01: results
main challenge
people's choice
#7 with 11 points.
pc runner up
#13 with 10 points.
mod's choice
#05
I've been in love with this icon from the second it popped up in my inbox! The use of the provided texture is absolutely stunning, and it blends with the text so well. My only issue is that Zelda looks a bit sharp around the edges?
bonus challenge
people's choice
#4 with 12 points.
pc runner up (tie)
#3 & #6 with 10 points each.
mod's choice
#1
I adore this icon! I like how it's not cluttered with textures, which allows the typography to shine!
02-01: tallies
If there is a / in your tally, the number after it stands for the additional critiques that were not worth any points. B stands for bonus icon.
01 +2 (+4, -2)/2
02 -7 (+0, -7)/1 B: +2/1
03 +6 (+7, -1)/1
04 -2 (+3, -5)/2
05 +7 (+9, -2) B: +11
06 +9 (+9, -0) B: +12
07 +11 (+11, -0) B: +1/2
08 +5 (+6, -1)/1 B: +11
09 -7 (+0, -7)/3
10 -10 (+0, -10)/1 B: +2/1
11 -2 (+1, -3)/1 B: +5
12 -6 (+0, -6)/1
13 10 (+10, -0)/1
Rankings are here.
LOOOOL PROBABLY NOT TONIGHT. I have a busy day (AGAIN! And it's not even because we're celebrating the goddamn holidays! Our tree isn't even up ahahahaha OTZ) tomorrow and I should go to bed pretty soon, and I haven't even bothered to keep track of who promoted yet, so I'll sort all of the rankings out tomorrow.
If you would like your critiques, please reply to this post with your identity and/or your icon's number. I will reply to it with a screened post, so please make sure you have notifications turned on!
I can PM or email you your crits instead, or I can leave them unscreened if you would like, just let me know.
Be sure to keep your identity secret and don't promote your icons until the round is over!
The third challenge is already up and can be found here! Two of you have already submitted! ♥
EDIT: I've responded to all crits as of 12/22 at 11:15 PM PST, and a few of you notified me of LJ having not emailing comments to you, so let me know if you haven't gotten anything and I can PM your critiques to you.