Round #002; Challenge #03: Results
Here are the results for Round #002 Challenge #03!
Challenge #002;03 Eliminations;
Erm, because of the way the voting ended up and how many people were disqualified this week, we decided to only eliminate two icons, not three. >_>;;
[#04]
by __lost_x3 (-14 points)
[#07]
by fearthechopstic (-10 points)
Challenge #002;03 Disqualifications (did not submit on time/no remaining byes);
faith_nyaa
rockettttt
warstench
Challenge #002;03 Withdrawls;
inverte
wolf_crossbreed
To those of you who have been eliminated (not disqualified), you will have an opportunity to rejoin the round with the Comeback Challenge that we will run half-way through the round. The top THREE icon makers of the Comeback Challenge (by popular vote) will be invited to rejoin the round in the following Challenge.
We're sorry to see you out, but please stick around and vote!
Challenge #002;03 People's Choice;
[#03]
by kerilu (+11 favorites)
Challenge #002;03 Mods' Choice;
[#10]
by _blurplinkle_
xenylamine's comments;
Great crop and coloring, it's so soft and muted. I love how you've more or less framed the band members with the black at the bottom, which adds just enough without shifting the focus. The lights also draw the eye to the center of the icon, making the image and not the text the visual, despite the contrasting color of the text. Nice job!
mihakken's comments;
The icon is dark, but with the crop it works well. I really like the uneven edge, and the placement of that edge compared to the text...overall, the space was used in a way that makes the icon feel finished.
The People's Choice and Mods' Choice icons are eligible for banners; please comment if you would like one.
Challenge #002;03 Results Tally;
icon #; -vote offs +favorites = total points
#01; -10 +1 = -9 points
#02; -2 +6 = +4 points
#03; -2 +11 = +9 points
#04; -14 +0 = -14 points
#05; -9 +1 = -8 points
#06; -8 +1 = -7 points
#07; -10 +0 = -10 points
#08; -8 +3 = -5 points
#09; -10 +1 = -9 points
#10; -2 +6 = +4 points
For reference, you can find the voting post HERE.
If you would like to know the critiques your icon received, respond to this post with your icon number and I will reply to your comment with the critiques, both positive and negative. Comments with critiques will be screened so that no one will be able to see them, but they will be emailed to you as a LJ comment reply from me. If you are not e-mailed your critiques, please let me know and I will e-mail them to you directly. All critiques will remain strictly anonymous. Please do not ask to know who voted for your icon, because we will not tell you. Please note that some of the critiques are harsh, so do not ask for your critiques if you will not be able to handle it.
There are 17 icon makers remaining in Round #002. Only the icon makers that survived Challenge #03 may submit an icon for Challenge #04.
Thank you everyone for your participation and effort!
Challenge #002;03 Eliminations;
Erm, because of the way the voting ended up and how many people were disqualified this week, we decided to only eliminate two icons, not three. >_>;;
[#04]
by __lost_x3 (-14 points)
[#07]
by fearthechopstic (-10 points)
Challenge #002;03 Disqualifications (did not submit on time/no remaining byes);
faith_nyaa
rockettttt
warstench
Challenge #002;03 Withdrawls;
inverte
wolf_crossbreed
To those of you who have been eliminated (not disqualified), you will have an opportunity to rejoin the round with the Comeback Challenge that we will run half-way through the round. The top THREE icon makers of the Comeback Challenge (by popular vote) will be invited to rejoin the round in the following Challenge.
We're sorry to see you out, but please stick around and vote!
Challenge #002;03 People's Choice;
[#03]
by kerilu (+11 favorites)
Challenge #002;03 Mods' Choice;
[#10]
by _blurplinkle_
xenylamine's comments;
Great crop and coloring, it's so soft and muted. I love how you've more or less framed the band members with the black at the bottom, which adds just enough without shifting the focus. The lights also draw the eye to the center of the icon, making the image and not the text the visual, despite the contrasting color of the text. Nice job!
mihakken's comments;
The icon is dark, but with the crop it works well. I really like the uneven edge, and the placement of that edge compared to the text...overall, the space was used in a way that makes the icon feel finished.
The People's Choice and Mods' Choice icons are eligible for banners; please comment if you would like one.
Challenge #002;03 Results Tally;
icon #; -vote offs +favorites = total points
#01; -10 +1 = -9 points
#02; -2 +6 = +4 points
#03; -2 +11 = +9 points
#04; -14 +0 = -14 points
#05; -9 +1 = -8 points
#06; -8 +1 = -7 points
#07; -10 +0 = -10 points
#08; -8 +3 = -5 points
#09; -10 +1 = -9 points
#10; -2 +6 = +4 points
For reference, you can find the voting post HERE.
If you would like to know the critiques your icon received, respond to this post with your icon number and I will reply to your comment with the critiques, both positive and negative. Comments with critiques will be screened so that no one will be able to see them, but they will be emailed to you as a LJ comment reply from me. If you are not e-mailed your critiques, please let me know and I will e-mail them to you directly. All critiques will remain strictly anonymous. Please do not ask to know who voted for your icon, because we will not tell you. Please note that some of the critiques are harsh, so do not ask for your critiques if you will not be able to handle it.
There are 17 icon makers remaining in Round #002. Only the icon makers that survived Challenge #03 may submit an icon for Challenge #04.
Thank you everyone for your participation and effort!