Eliminated:
alchemyfreak123 with -4 votes
sorry to see you go! :(
People's Choice:
spunkprincess with +1 votes
congratulations! :)
Mod's Choice:
lillianportergreat use of color, crop & repetition
The Voting Tally:
Just in case you forgot your icon number, you can check
HERE01. -5+1=-4
02. 0
03. -4+1=-3
04. -1
05. -1+2=+1
06. -3+3=0
07. -3+1=-2
08. -3+2=-1
09. -2+1=-1
Lesser Quality Icons
1 - the icon seems a little blurry
1 - too much going on
1 - text is clearly unnecessary
1 - The icon lacks a bit of contrast
1 - the text behind looks a little too much
3 - the colouring is a little dull and the texture distracting
3 - very strange texture
3 - bad use of texture and lowers the icon quality
3 - The background texture doesn't fit well with the picture
4 - colors are dirty a little, not very good use of duplication
5 - colors are too brownish and the icon is blurry a little
6 - the frame doesn't suit the subject
6 - strangely empty top
6 - subject too small
7 - needs a bit more sharpening and colour
7 - a bit under-done; could have used better coloring
7 - nice cropping but needs more colour
8 - text is a bit hard to read
8 - too blurry, the icon looks boring because of vague coloring
8 - the crop is a bit boring, could be brighter
9 - needs more colouring
9 - The colouring makes the picture seems too pale
Favorite icons:
1 - Rob looks a little bit blurry but the whole icon is nicely made, good use of text (+ it's funny, haha), nice composition as well
3 - wonderful coloring
4 - very creative and interesting, nice use of blending
4 - interesting idea and color
4 - really good blending and effect using the image
5 - beautiful color and using text
5 - great colouring and place of text
6 - interesting composition, matched colors, good use of texture(s)
6 - excellent croping and nice use of texture
6 - Nice composition overall and original use of negative space
7 - original and nice colouring
8 - great colouring and place of text
8 - Good colouring and use of text
9 - great composition and coloring
If you have any questions please let us know in the comments!