Just an update...
We did not get our dream house. Nate called me at 4:00 and told me that an offer had already been put down and accepted over the weekend. Our realtor said we could do a counter offer for more, but we didn't want to play the game, especially since it was the 2nd house we've ever looked at, so we took it as a sign that it wasn't meant to be and to keep looking. I was really bummed at first of course, but now it's OK, and I'm ready to continue the search.