Challenge 02 Round 05 Results

Nov 02, 2008 18:52

I'm so sorry, but we have to say "goodbye" to some participants.



Eliminated:


value with 3 votes



messdestruction with 2 votes

People's Choice:


tulipsprincess with 4 votes

Mod's Choice:


tory_guvera
Good colouring and cropping!

Did you forget your icon number? You can find it HERE

Voting Tally:
01| -2+1= -1
02| -2
03| -2+3= 1
04| +4
05| -3
06| -1+1= 0
07| -2+3= +1

Favourite icons
01 - quite sympathetic color, nicely cropped image

03 - nice crop and colorings brings up her hair nicely
3 - nice crop :D
003 - Good coloring, but crop is a little bit too centered.

004 - good cropping.
4- great coloring, and use of texture
004 - Great colors use
04 - though the coloring could be brighter, the icon in general looks nice, the textures are used good

06 - nice crop and quality though the texture of the moon doesn't look weel

7- gr8 use of textures
7 - cute texture use
007 - Great texture choice

Lesser quality icons
001 - The light is little weird
001: Too much magenta, oversharpened.

2 - wow! too dark and oversharped
2- the coloring is so dark, I can't even see her face

3- the cropping is boring, could've been much better
003 - The cropping is not original

5 - oversharped and text is too distracting
05 - the coloring is rather dull and the text is too big and distracting
05 - composition is distructed of rotated image and too big text. style of text isn't nice

006: Texture is overpowering, icon is busy.

07 - texture on the right side just makes worse icon. bad choice of texture :\
07 - looks loke the texture was cut off on the top :( and in general the textures don't really fit in

results, challenge_02, round_05

Previous post Next post
Up